The Week The Week
flag of US
US
flag of UK
UK
https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/skoGBi9qKFoUtnNWkovjJQ.jpg

SUBSCRIBE

Try 6 Free Issues

Sign in
  • View Profile
  • Sign out
  • The Explainer
  • Talking Points
  • The Week Recommends
  • Podcasts
  • Newsletters
  • From the Magazine
  • The Week Junior
  • More
    • Politics
    • World News
    • Business
    • Health
    • Science
    • Food & Drink
    • Travel
    • Culture
    • History
    • Personal Finance
    • Puzzles
    • Photos
    • The Blend
    • All Categories
  • Newsletter sign up Newsletter
  • The Week Evening Review
    Mandelson under scrutiny, AI minsters, and hospital rankings

     
    TODAY’S BIG QUESTION

    What does Mandelson drama mean for Keir Starmer?

    Peter Mandelson has been appointed to the three most recent Labour governments and has now been fired from all three. Pressure is growing on Keir Starmer to explain why he gambled on the Labour peer again, as Conservatives demand the publication of all vetting material around his appointment as the UK’s ambassador to the US.

    What did the commentators say?
    Mandelson is gone but “questions about the prime minister’s judgement remain”, said the BBC. He decided that “being friends with a convicted paedophile in the past should not exclude someone from high public office”, but further details this week “changed the PM’s view”. Many Labour MPs think Starmer “should have seen this scandal a mile off”.

    His “public image is one of stolid caution”, said Emma Burnell in The Guardian, but Starmer “is actually something of a political risk-taker”, and caution and risk were “both on display” when he “took a leap by vocally standing by Mandelson” but then “fell back on the fact that Mandelson was vetted for the role”.

    Where he “once claimed sole custody of what few ethics were left in Westminster”, said Patrick Maguire in The Times, in just six days Starmer has “lost two of his government’s household names to scandals whose details might have been designed to vindicate the public’s disappearing trust in the political mainstream”.

    Even before he “bowed to the inevitable”, the prime minister’s “judgement” was “under fresh scrutiny”, said Kitty Donaldson in The i Paper, because “what was obvious to the backbenchers appeared to be less clear to No. 10”. He was “already seen as out of touch” with his MPs and now he’s “facing serious questions about his future”.

    What next?
    The outgoing chief of MI6 has emerged as “one of the early frontrunners” to replace Mandelson, said The Telegraph – Richard Moore would "bring decades of experience”. Other favourites include Mark Sedwill, Boris Johnson’s national security adviser, and Barbara Woodward, Britain’s permanent representative to the UN. If a replacement can’t be installed before Donald Trump’s state visit next week, interim ambassador James Roscoe will lead preparations for the visit.

     
     
    IN THE SPOTLIGHT

    Albania’s AI minister: a sign of things to come?

    Albania has appointed an AI bot as its new anti-corruption minister as artificial intelligence increasingly infiltrates the world of politics. Known as Diella, which means “sun” in Albanian, it’s hoped that the new AI minister will be “impervious to bribes, threats, or attempts to curry favour”, said Reuters.

    ‘Sticking point’
    Diella was originally launched earlier this year as an AI-powered virtual assistant to help citizens and businesses obtain state documents. Now she’s “the first cabinet member who isn’t physically present, but is virtually created by AI”, said Prime Minister Edi Rama as he unveiled his new cabinet. She’ll help make Albania “a country where public tenders are 100% free of corruption”, he promised.

    The awarding of public tender contracts is a particularly sensitive issue in Albania – it has “long been a source of corruption scandals”, said Reuters. Albania wants to join the European Union by 2030 and corruption is a “sticking point”, said Euronews, so the government is keen to be seen to be cracking down on it.

    But not everyone is convinced Diella is the answer. “Even Diella will be corrupted in Albania,” said one Facebook user and another predicted that “stealing will continue and Diella will be blamed”.

    ‘Castle in the air’
    The use of AI in politics is becoming more and more mainstream. A youth movement in Nepal this week used ChatGPT to suggest potential candidates for interim prime minister, then asked it to “debate the pros and cons” of each, said The Times. Again, there are sceptics. To change laws “you need research, legitimacy and a real mandate”, a Nepali wrote on a forum. Choosing a candidate with AI is “like building a castle in the air”.

    Closer to home, MPs in Westminster are “frequently resorting” to ChatGPT to write speeches, according to analysis of Hansard, the parliamentary record. “Phrases such as ‘I rise to speak’ and ‘I rise today’, which ChatGPT regularly suggests as a way to begin speeches in the House of Commons, have surged since the release of the AI tool in 2022,” said The Telegraph.

     
     

    Poll watch

    The majority of Americans (57%) believe the president should not have the power to control police in large cities, according to a Reuters/Ipsos survey conducted as Donald Trump threatens to extend his federal crime crackdown beyond Washington. Opposition to such presidential interference in their own home city was even greater among the 1,084 adults polled, at 62%.

     
     

    Statistic of the day

    12,533: The number of inmates still on the run as of this morning following mass prison breaks in Nepal, according to a police spokesperson. Around 13,500 prisoners escaped amid the civil disorder engulfing the country in the wake of the government’s violent crackdown on anti-corruption protests.

     
     
    THE EXPLAINER

    Hospital league tables: how does the new ranking work?

    The first football-style NHS league tables, which rank the best- and worst-performing hospitals and trusts in England, have been published. Available to the public, they will be reassessed every three months.

    Health Secretary Wes Streeting said he hopes league tables will increase transparency and bring “the best of the NHS to the rest of the NHS”, but health experts have warned that the new system lacks nuance and could even “prompt patients to avoid seeking help”, said The Guardian.

    How does the system work?
    Each trust is assigned a score between one (the highest) and four based on their performance across six domains: access to services, effectiveness and experience of care, patient safety, staff wellbeing, fiscal responsibility, and improving health and reducing inequality. Finances are also taken into account; “it is possible that a hospital rated highly for clinical care will be marked down if they are running up a larger than expected deficit”, said the BBC.

    NHS leaders at top-ranked trusts may be offered bonuses or temporary pay raises “to go into the lower-ranked organisations and turn them around”; those leading the “worst performers” might see their pay frozen or docked, said The Telegraph.

    What do the results show?
    Specialist trusts including Moorfields Eye Hospital, the Royal National Orthopaedic Hospital and The Christie NHS Foundation Trust topped the table, while The Queen Elizabeth Hospital in King’s Lynn, Norfolk, received the worst rating.

    But NHS England said while the table “can be a helpful indicator of potential areas of disparity for further investigation”, comparisons should be made “cautiously”.

    Why are some experts urging caution?
    Tables “don’t tell you in simple terms” how a hospital is performing, Sarah Woolnough, chief executive of the King’s Fund, told the BBC. “These rankings risk confusing people, rather than helping them choose where to get great care.”

    “As finances have a particular sway on the rankings”, the tables are “of limited use” for patients, Thea Stein, chief executive of the Nuffield Trust, told The Telegraph. There is also a risk that “trusts will focus only on the measures that immediately boost their ranking”, even if those measures aren’t necessarily best for their patients.

     
     

    Good day 🐶

    … for nominative determinism, as Barking is revealed to be home to London’s noisiest dogs. Barking and Dagenham Council has received 2,239 complaints about noisy hounds in the past five years – more than any other borough. The City of London got the fewest, with only six complaints since 2020.

     
     

    Bad day 🗣️

    … for cross-cultural communication, as Apple blocks AirPod users in Europe from accessing a new “live translation” feature. The function, which offers automated real-time translation of several languages, has been disabled in the EU amid concerns it may not comply with regulations about compatibility with competitor devices.

     
     
    picture of the day

    War and peace

    An Israeli soldier gestures from an armoured vehicle close to the Gaza border. Residents have been told to leave Gaza City as Israel continues its military assault on the city, which Benjamin Netanyahu has called the “last important stronghold” of Hamas.

    Jack Guez / AFP / Getty Images

     
     
    PUZZLES AND QUIZZES

    Quiz of The Week

    Have you been paying attention to The Week's news? Try our weekly quiz, part of our puzzles section, which also includes sudoku and crosswords 

    Play here

     
     
    THE WEEK RECOMMENDS

    Properties of the week: converted shops 

    Berkshire: Gallery House, Hungerford
    An opportunity to convert an attractive Grade II property, formerly retail premises believed to date back to the 17th century (with later additions), into a modernised residential dwelling. 6 beds, 4 receps, 3 attic rooms, WC, large garden, detached outbuilding. £450,000; Strutt & Parker

    Norfolk: Stocks Green, King’s Lynn
    A handsome 18th-century property, part of the historic fabric of Castle Acre, which also hosts the owner’s apartment, restaurant/café and shop. A full handover will be provided. 2 beds, family bath, kitchen/dining room, recep, conservatory, 2 roof terraces, walled garden, outbuildings. £785,000; Savills

    Buckinghamshire: Beam House, Great Missenden
    This lovely Grade II village house dates back in part to the 15th century, and was used as a shop from the 18th century. Main suite, 3 further beds, family bath, kitchen, 3 receps, basement, garden, sun terrace. £1.25 million; Knight Frank

    Suffolk: 29 St John’s Place, Bury St Edmunds
    A stylish contemporary townhouse in a building that dates back to the 1920s and has previously served as commercial premises for many decades. 2 beds, shower room, open-plan living area, recep, study, covered courtyard. £750,000; Bedfords

    See more

     
     
    QUOTE OF THE DAY

    “No, that wasn’t a mistake.”

    Poland’s Foreign Minister Radosław Sikorski responds on X to Donald Trump’s suggestion that Russia’s drone incursion into Polish airspace “could have been a mistake”. Prime Minister Donald Tusk has requested an emergency UN Security Council meeting in New York today.

     
     
    instant opinion

    Today's best commentary

    Macron has defied the will of the people. He leaves the French public no choice but to Block Everything
    Rokhaya Diallo in The Guardian
    The “hallmark” of Emmanuel Macron’s presidency is his “persistent disregard for the will of the people”, writes French journalist and activist Rokhaya Diallo. His government’s “combined unfairness and heavy-handedness” is what “people so vehemently oppose now – in the streets and at the ballot box”. I’m “not surprised at the public defiance”: “policies that deepen social hardship are intolerable for those told to tighten their belts”, especially “while the wealthy – idolised by Macron – grow richer still”.

    NHS could be critical for Labour to halt the march of Nigel Farage
    Martin Bagot in The Mirror
    There’s “one issue which could derail the Reform UK bandwagon”, writes Martin Bagot. The NHS is the “one thing that still unites us”, leaving “former City trader” Nigel Farage “at odds with the rest of Britain” when he “sings the praises of the French insurance-based system”. The “private school educated Brexiteer” has suggested that he’s “open to re-examining the NHS’s funding model”, a prospect that will “send a shudder through middle England” and the “traditional working classes”.

    I’m middle-class and proud – stop the sneering
    Emma Duncan in The Times
    “I’m cheesed off by the celebration of the working classes and the denigration of the middle classes,” writes Emma Duncan. It’s “bad for the country”, because “middle-class values and habits” are “those on which decent family and national life are built”. The middle classes are an “industrious lot” who are “disinclined to blame society when things go wrong” and “averse to ostentation”. It’s time for a “middle-class pride movement”, with a flag in a “tasteful blend from the Farrow and Ball palette”.

     
     
    word of the day

    Canticle

    Biblical verses set to music, usually sung by a church choir during services. Bangor Cathedral has suspended its choir for performing an unauthorised “Canticle of Indignation” during a holy communion, to protest against staffing cuts. In a statement, church officials said the performance, which ended with a silent walkout, was “entirely inappropriate”.

     
     

    In the morning

    Keep an eye on your inbox for Saturday Wrap, which includes an in-depth look inside the mind of Benjamin Netanyahu.

    Have a great weekend and thanks for reading,
    Rebecca

     
     

     Evening Review was written and edited by Rebecca Messina, Jamie Timson, Chas Newkey-Burden, Abby Wilson, Irenie Forshaw, David Edwards and Kari Wilkin, with illustrations by Stephen Kelly.

    Image credits, from top: Carl Court / AFP / Getty Images; Illustration by Stephen Kelly / Getty Images; Richard Baker / In Pictures / Getty Images; Jack Guez / AFP / Getty Images; Knight Frank / Michael Graham / Savills / Bedfords

    Morning Report and Evening Review were named Newsletter of the Year at the Publisher Newsletter Awards 2025
     

    Recent editions

    • Morning Report

      Hunt for killer of Charlie Kirk intensifies

    • Evening Review

      Are ‘super-universities’ the future?

    • Morning Report

      Trump ally Charlie Kirk shot dead

    VIEW ALL
    TheWeek
    • About Us
    • Contact Future's experts
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy
    • Advertise With Us

    The Week UK is part of Future plc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.

    © Future Publishing Limited Quay House, The Ambury, Bath BA1 1UA. All rights reserved. England and Wales company registration number 2008885.