For some, it was threatening to wipe out an entire civilisation; for others, it was posting an image of himself as Jesus. But whatever the trigger, questions are now being asked openly about whether Donald Trump is mentally fit to hold the office of US president.
“Let’s not pussyfoot around talking about his ‘erratic’ or ‘unpredictable’ behaviour,” said former Guardian editor Alan Rusbridger in The Independent. “Let’s just say all the signs are that he is positively unhinged.”
What did the commentators say? Calling the US president insane “is not meant as playground abuse”, said Matthew Parris in The Times. By saying that, “I mean Donald Trump is mentally ill; that he is of unsound mind; that he is suffering from substantial cognitive decline”. If he worked at a bank, as a pilot, a solicitor or GP, or in many other lesser offices than the American presidency, “urgent discussions would be taking place among colleagues about his mental fitness for the post”.
A Reuters-Ipsos poll in February found that 61% of Americans, including 30% of Republicans, believed Trump had become more “erratic with age”, while the number of people who believed he was “mentally sharp and capable of handling challenges” had fallen from 54% in 2023 to 45%. But for his supporters, the president’s increasingly erratic behaviour is merely proof of his “unorthodox personality”, said Iker Seisdedos in El País. They argue that this is simply the “unpredictable and approachable style of someone who has no regard for the conventions of traditional politics”.
What next? Last week, House Democrats put forward legislation to create a commission to assess whether Trump is unfit to serve. But passing the bill “is a long shot in a Republican-controlled Congress”, said Arwa Mahdawi in The Guardian.
Two years ago, Congressional Republicans eagerly scrutinised Joe Biden’s “every word, his every stumble, even the mechanics of how he signed documents”, said Juan Williams in The Hill, but that “chorus of critics on Capitol Hill is now silent”. Most of those in Trump’s own party “apparently think their responsibility” is to back him no matter what – even if that means an “unsteady hand in control of the nation’s nuclear arsenal”.
|