Public figures have joined friends of Jason Arday to call for a public inquiry into the “witch hunt” faced by the former Cambridge professor before his death. Labour MP Diane Abbott, actor Jameela Jamil and Green Party leader Zack Polanski are among 30,000 signatories of a letter to the prime minister about the “relentless harassment” suffered by Arday amid media allegations of plagiarism and questions about some of his claimed achievements. Last night, thousands of mourners gathered in London’s Trafalgar Square for a vigil organised by Stand Up to Racism.
‘Institutional murder’ The Spectator and The Telegraph ran “article after article about Arday”, said University of Oxford professor Sneha Krishnan on Al Jazeera, but there were also attacks from the left, including Novara Media. “Many academics are investigated for misconduct in their scholarship” but “none should involve public shaming or racist glee”. Arday’s “harassment and death” is tantamount to “institutional murder” by a media ecosystem that has repeatedly shown itself to be “infused with anti-Black racism”.
Getting to the bottom of plagiarism allegations is “in the public interest”, said Stephen Bush in the Financial Times, and for the sake of Cambridge University and its academic integrity, “exposure does matter”. But in this case, the coverage was never free from a “miasma of race”.
This was a “death by a thousand headlines”, said Alan Rusbridger in Prospect. “Torrents of verbiage cascaded” from journalists, but none of it was directed at the “troubled history” of Nathan Cofnas, the “race realist” who “claimed the credit for unmasking Arday”. Unfortunately, “Fleet Street in full pursuit can only manage one narrative at a time”.
‘Media did its job properly’ “The basic job of the press is to find out the truth,” said Charles Moore in The Telegraph. And it discovered “substantial untruths, seriously damaging to the reputation“ of one of our greatest universities, “and reported them”. Arday denied allegations of plagiarism but acknowledged errors in his work.
“The media is the only institution in this entire tragic scandal that did its job properly,” said Brendan O’Neill in The Spectator. The leftist spin is that “hacks hounded him into despair”, but the truth is that journalists “found a story and they told it” – unlike Arday’s colleagues who “failed to prize merit over identity”.
|