The end of smoking?
At one time, half the U.S. population smoked. Today, most smokers have quit. What happened?
At one time, half the U.S. population smoked. Today, most smokers have quit. What happened? Here's everything you need to know:
How many people smoke today?
In the U.S., just 17.8 percent of the population smokes — a record low, and down from a peak of more than 50 percent in the 1950s. Punishing taxes, indoor-smoking bans, and gruesome ad campaigns have compelled smokers to quit at such a rate that Citigroup analysts predict their numbers could drop to nearly zero by 2050. This decline is largely the result of a remarkable change in public perception of smoking, which the tobacco industry had successfully portrayed as cool and rebellious — a mark of sophistication and maturity. Now smokers are largely pariahs, and smoking is widely seen as a dangerous, dirty, and disgusting habit. Fifty years ago, "everyone around me smoked," says photo developer Barry Blackwell, 60. "Everyone." Now, looking down on smokers is "one of the few socially acceptable prejudices left."
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
Join more than 350,000 subscribers and keep yourself informed with a selection of The Week’s most interesting, enlightening and entertaining stories - plus daily puzzles.
Join more than 350,000 subscribers and keep yourself informed with a selection of The Week’s most interesting, enlightening and entertaining stories - plus daily puzzles.
Why have smoking rates dropped so dramatically?
Fewer teens are starting to smoke in the first place, which helps. But a wave of state and city smoking bans for indoor spaces, including offices, restaurants, and bars, have also made it increasingly inconvenient for existing smokers to light up outside the home. In the aftermath of those bans, a 2012 study showed, hospitalizations for heart attacks and strokes fell at least 15 percent. The public-smoking bans did not merely force smokers to light up at home, as many health officials first feared, but have actually encouraged large numbers to kick the habit entirely. The percentage of smoke-free homes in Minnesota, following bans on restaurant, bar, and workplace smoking, for example, grew from 64.5 percent in 1999 to 87.2 percent in 2010.
What about ad campaigns?
Television ads have proved a hugely successful way of rebranding smoking. One campaign in particular terrified huge numbers of smokers into chucking away their cigarettes: the 2012 "Tips From Former Smokers" campaign by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), which featured harrowing videos of people who'd developed cancer, diabetes, emphysema, and other diseases as a result of smoking. "During radiation treatments I'm still smoking because I'm that addicted," said one of the former smokers, who had a mechanical voice and prominent tracheotomy hole in his throat. "It wasn't until they took out my voice box and I breathed through a hole in my neck that I finally quit." In the three months after these ads aired, 200,000 Americans quit smoking. CDC Director Tom Frieden says the ads represented a "David vs. Goliath" victory against the tobacco industry, which spends about $8 billion annually marketing its products. "Because we have truth on our side," said Frieden, "these ads make a difference."
Stories of progress and joy, delivered every Thursday
Do cigarette taxes help?
Hitting smokers in the wallet has proved the most effective strategy. In 2009, President Obama signed a historic federal tax hike that raised cigarette prices 22 percent overnight; the following year, 3 million fewer people said they smoked. These days, smoking is a very expensive habit to have: In New York City, the average price of a single pack of cigarettes is $13. Hard-core smokers who can withstand smoking bans and ad campaigns about smoking's dangers find it harder to ignore cost considerations, said Dr. Mary O. Sullivan, director of the Margarita Camche Smoking Cessation Program. "Even our schizophrenia patients, who are the most addicted, who used to smoke two and three packs a day, even they are smoking less because of the price," O'Sullivan told The New York Times.
Is smoking dying out everywhere?
Unfortunately, no. In the developing world, the trend has been exactly the reverse: Tobacco consumption more than doubled between 1970 and 2000, and three-quarters of the world's smokers now live in developing countries such as Nigeria, India, and China. Tobacco companies have flocked to these countries to boost profits, and governments in the region are profiting from the trend. In China, home of 340 million smokers, cigarette taxes generate up to 10 percent of total annual central government revenues. In the long run, however, the huge health costs of treating hundreds of millions of smokers are sure to catch up with China and other countries, and they will probably follow the West's lead in trying to discourage smoking.
What's the future of smoking?
It's not dead yet. Even after decades of decline in the U.S., 42 million people still smoke, and smoking causes 500,000 deaths a year. And while smoking rates dropped 62 percent among high-income families from 1965 to 1999, they dropped only 9 percent among low-income families. Trends suggest that the number of smokers will continue to creep down; regulations that lower the amount of nicotine in cigarettes could help speed up that process. But unless the government makes smoking illegal, millions will continue to smoke. As epidemiologist Catherine Hill points out, only 70 percent of current smokers say they actually want to quit. "Ambitious goals for a smoke-free society," she says, "do not take this simple fact of life into account."
E-cigs: The next generation's habit
For today's teenagers, smoking cigarettes is no longer a widespread rite of passage. More of them smoke marijuana than tobacco, and a growing number are attracted to e-cigarettes — battery-powered handheld devices that heat up nicotine-laced fluid, vaporizing it for users to inhale. As teen cigarette use has dropped from 23 percent in 2000 to 9 percent today, e-cig experimentation among high schoolers has soared, tripling in just one year to 13 percent. In theory, that could be a good thing: E-cigs are tobacco- and smoke-free, so they don't cause the severe lung damage of cigarettes — though studies have found formaldehyde, benzene, and other toxins in the devices' secondhand vapor. But a recent study found that e-cigs can start teens down the road to regular cigarette use, since they, too, get people addicted to nicotine. "While e-cigarettes may potentially represent a product that can reduce harm for established cigarette smokers," the study authors said, "they may simultaneously contribute to the development of a new population of cigarette smokers."