Debate: is Keir Starmer making Labour great again - or letting Boris Johnson off the hook?

Keir Starmer had a long list of headaches when he arrived for his first day as leader of the opposition back in early April.

With Labour still licking its wounds after its worst election defeat since 1935, and the coronavirus crisis escalating, how Starmer would set about rebuilding his party was a key question.

But five months on, Starmer’s star appears to be rising, with Labour level with the Conservatives in recent polling. So should Boris Johnson be worried?

The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

‘Make Labour Great Again’

As Politico’s chief UK correspondent Charlie Cooper writes, the challenge facing Starmer is a “surprisingly Trumpian mission: (Re)build the wall”.

Having seen Labour’s red wall electoral stronghold decimated in the December vote, “winning back those voters is mission critical if Starmer is to stand any chance of becoming Britain’s next prime minister” - and “his team has had them firmly in mind”.

The party’s post-mortem following the election found that along with issues including Brexit and voters’ doubts about Jeremy Corbyn, the wipeout was the “culmination of a decade or more in which old party loyalties based on class have loosened and given way to cultural divides on identity”, Cooper adds.

So “there’s some irony” in critics accusing Starmer of being “too timid” and show a lack of “revolutionary instincts”, says ex-chief prosecutor Nazir Afzal, who worked under the Labour leader when he was director of public prosecutions.

Instead, Afzal writes in an article for HuffPost, Starmer “is currently pursuing the most radical idea in politics” - rebuilding trust.

This push appears to be bearing fruit. The New Statesman reports that polling shows “more Brits now view Labour as competent and capable” then under Corbyn.

“A notable trend for Labour since Starmer became leader has been a steady drop in the number of voters with an unfavourable opinion about the party,” the magazine says. “In the run-up to the 2019 election, nearly half of Brits viewed Labour negatively. That has now fallen to 39%.”

This is not lost on Starmer’s inner circle, one of whom told Politico’s Cooper that “one of their top priorities… has been the task of ‘establishing Keir”.

Cooper points to opinion articles written by Starmer for right-wing newspapers, and the Labour leader’s appeals to patriotism, as examples of this bid to “put down markers about his political and moral values”.

As the PR offensive gathers pace, the New Statesman says that “there’s little question that Keir Starmer has impressed as a formidable leader of the opposition”.

But is he tough enough?

One criticism levelled at Starmer is that he has not been forceful enough in his attacks on Johnson’s government during the coronavirus pandemic.

In an article in The Guardian in April, Tony Blair’s former spin doctor Alistair Campbell wrote that Starmer should “show no mercy” in exposing mistakes made by government ministers.

Calling on the Labour leader to “take the gloves off”, Campbell said “it has been noticeable how rarely, at government briefings and interviews, questions have been framed by things Labour has said or done; that must change”.

Former shadow chancellor John McDonnell has also criticised his boss from the backbenches, tweeting that “it’s not opposition for opposition’s sake to call out [government’s] failure to pursue effective test & track programme & supply basic protection to front line staff & to neglect support for care homes & care workers”.

This is at odds with Starmer’s calls for constructive opposition, although he has become more critical of the government’s handling of the coronavirus pandemic. In an article for The Guardian in early August, he wrote: “We accept that no one could have handled coronavirus perfectly.

“But the truth is that the government has been too slow to act throughout this crisis – too slow into lockdown, too slow on testing and too slow getting PPE to front-line workers.”

What are the upcoming challenges?

As has become the norm for the Labour Party in recent years, many of Starmer’s most pressing problems have originated among his own MPs.

In July, the party agreed in the High Court to pay undisclosed six-figure settlements for making “false and defamatory” comments about ex-employees who spoke out last year in a BBC Panorama documentary titled Is Labour Anti-Semitic?.

Corbyn and his followers, including Unite leader Len McCluskey, attacked the payout, with the Daily Mail warning that “the move could reignite factional infighting with the party’s hard-left element”.

The Spectator’s Isabel Hardman argues that “Labour MPs who weren't Corbyn fans (which was most of them) are so relieved that Starmer has taken over that they are willing to forgive a great deal”.

But “what does worry supportive MPs is that Starmer’s main pitch is one of competence”, she adds. “At the moment, they say, that’s perfect as he’s responding to the government’s handling of the coronavirus epidemic.”

But “one currently loyal MP” told Hardman that “being self-evidently competent is necessary but not sufficient”.

“You need to be able to set some fires too,” said the insider. “It’s pretty rare for people just to vote for competence. They also need to vote for something they feel enthusiastic about.”