Utah death penalty: is a firing squad really 'more humane'?
Utah becomes the only US state to approve death by firing squad because of a shortage of lethal injections
Utah has reintroduced death by firing squad for inmates on Death Row in cases where the drugs for lethal injections are unavailable.
The state's governor Gary Herbert signed the bill into law this week. He admitted that he found the method "a little bit gruesome" but said the state required a back-up execution method.
"We prefer to use our primary method of lethal injection when such a sentence is issued," the governor's spokesman said, according to the BBC.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
"However, when a jury makes the decision and a judge signs a death warrant, enforcing that lawful decision is the obligation of the executive branch."
The controversial issue has polarised politicians. Many argue that it is a faster and more humane form of execution but opponents insist that it would be a throwback to the state's Wild West days. Civil rights groups say the move makes Utah "look backward and backwoods".
How does a firing squad work?
Inmates are typically strapped to a chair, with a target pinned over their heart. A hood is placed over their heads and law enforcement officers, standing at a distance of 25ft, aim for the target with their .30-caliber rifles.
"As in traditional military firing squads, one of those shooters' guns will be loaded with blanks to keep each one uncertain about whether he fired a fatal shot," says Slate.
There have been only three executions by firing squad in the US since 1976, according to the Washington-based Death Penalty Information Center.
Why has it been introduced?
Utah is just one of several states seeking alternative execution methods following a shortage of lethal injections, as European drug companies opposed to the death penalty refuse to supply components of the drug. This has led executioners to experiment with drug cocktails that have led to a number of botched executions.
The legislation reinstates the use of firing squads more than a decade after the practice was outlawed in Utah. Lethal injection would be kept as the primary method of execution, but authorities would be allowed to use marksmen if the drugs were unavailable.
The debate
The legislation's proponents argue that death by firing squad is far more humane than lethal injection, because it's quicker. In one study, monitors registered complete heart death in less than a minute after an inmate was shot. A "typical, complication-free" lethal injection, on the other hand, takes roughly nine minutes to kill a prisoner. Last year, convicted murderer Clayton Lockett took 43 minutes to die.
The legislation would give the state more options, said the bill's sponsor, Republican Paul Ray. "We would love to get the lethal injection worked out so we can continue with that but if not, we now have a back-up plan," he said.
Opponents argue that the method is gruesome, outdated and "a relic of a more barbaric past". "I think Utah took a giant step backward," Ralph Dellapiana, director of Utahns for Alternatives to the Death Penalty, told the Associated Press.
The Death Penalty Information Center says that a firing squad is not a foolproof method of execution, as the prisoner could move or marksmen could miss the heart, which would cause a slower and more painful death.
For some Republican politicians, the method of execution is irrelevant. "I realise this may sound harsh," Mike Christian told the BBC after Lockett's botched execution, "but as a father and former lawman, I really don't care if it's by lethal injection, the electric chair, firing squad, hanging, the guillotine or being fed to the lions".
For others the debate "has a ring of the absurd", as no method of execution can ever be humane, says the BBC. "Those opposed in principle to the death penalty believe all its forms are immoral and arguments about methods are irrelevant."
Create an account with the same email registered to your subscription to unlock access.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
-
The pros and cons of globalization
Pros and Cons Globalization can promote economic prosperity but also be exploitative
By Justin Klawans, The Week US Published
-
Magazine solutions - October 11, 2024
Puzzles and Quizzes Issue - October 11, 2024
By The Week US Published
-
Magazine printables - October 11, 2024
Puzzles and Quizzes Issue - October 11, 2024
By The Week US Published
-
Row over pole-dancing skeleton
Tall Tales And other stories from the stranger side of life
By Chas Newkey-Burden, The Week UK Published
-
Ghana abolishes the death penalty
feature It joins a growing list of African countries which are turning away from capital punishment
By Rebekah Evans Published
-
Baby born using three people’s DNA
feature And other stories from the stranger side of life
By Chas Newkey-Burden Published
-
Singapore executes man for trafficking 1kg of cannabis
Speed Read Human rights organisations criticise city-state for hanging Singaporean man whose case was ‘far from clear cut’
By The Week Staff Published
-
A snowy winter helped Great Salt Lake water levels rise 3 feet above historic low
Speed Read
By Catherine Garcia Published
-
Pennsylvania governor says he won't sign execution orders, calls for repeal of the death penalty
Speed Read
By Theara Coleman Published
-
Thai fisherman finds whale vomit worth £2.4m
Speed Read And other stories from the stranger side of life
By The Week Staff Last updated
-
Supreme Court blocks Arkansas executions
Speed Read Prisoners Don Davis and Bruce Ward saved from the death penalty with just hours to spare
By The Week Staff Published