Feature

College football: Should players be paid?

Modern college football is a multibillion-dollar business—there’s nothing “amateur” about it.

“It’s time to pay college athletes,” said Sean Gregory in Time. That’s been obvious for years, and became even clearer this month when the football season kicked off minus its most captivating player: Heisman-winning quarterback Johnny Manziel. He was banned for half of Texas A&M’s season opener for “breaking the spirit” of the amateur game, after allegedly autographing memorabilia for a five-figure fee. But a glance at the multibillion-dollar business that is modern college football shows there’s nothing “amateur” about it. Manziel works a full-time job making tens of millions for his school, his coach—whose salary tops $3 million—and local businesses without seeing a penny of it himself. In an era when TV networks are paying billions for the rights to college games, establishing a small wage for college players—say, $30,000—isn’t just fair. “It’s an ethical imperative.”

College athletes do get a wage, said John Tamny in Forbes.com. It’s called a scholarship, and is worth up to $200,000 in tuition, room costs, and expenses. Your average student would kill for a free ride through college. And thanks to college sports, the athletes who hope for pro careers get specialized training and a highly visible platform on which to promote themselves and land million-dollar contracts in the NFL. A star like Manziel gets to “carry around a marketable name for life.” But what about Manziel’s teammates? said Joe Nocera in The New York Times. Most will never make it to the pros. And most of them are required to devote so much time to football that they often do not get a real education to fall back on.

The scholarship system isn’t ideal, said Jeffrey Dorfman in Forbes.com, but a wage scheme would create a nightmare of complications. Will the paychecks be equal, or will the star quarterback who sells the tickets and boosts TV ratings be paid more than the third-string long-snapper? What would stop the 10 or 20 richest, most successful colleges from buying “virtually all the best football and basketball players”? What happens to the 90 percent of college sports programs that already lose money? And will the women’s lacrosse team get a cut? If not, schools had better lawyer up to defend a Title IX suit for equal pay. Face it: Paying college athletes in the name of fairness “will just create new problems.’’

Recommended

Congress passes bill to aid U.S. diplomats and spies hit with 'Havana syndrome'
CIA Director William Burns
Havana syndrome

Congress passes bill to aid U.S. diplomats and spies hit with 'Havana syndrome'

Tigray and the shredding of international law
A Tigray child.
Picture of Ryan CooperRyan Cooper

Tigray and the shredding of international law

Thailand is turning plastic waste into personal protective equipment
A monk in Thailand wearing PPE made from plastic bottles.
getting creative

Thailand is turning plastic waste into personal protective equipment

Taliban foreign minister asks to address the United Nations
Taliban Foreign Minister Amir Khan Muttaqi.
seeking legitimacy

Taliban foreign minister asks to address the United Nations

Most Popular

Did Theranos Lose Afghanistan?
Elizabeth Holmes and James Mattis.
Samuel Goldman

Did Theranos Lose Afghanistan?

7 cartoons about America's vaccine fights
Editorial Cartoon.
Feature

7 cartoons about America's vaccine fights

Former FDA commissioner questions whether researchers should continue to publish sequences of novel viruses
Scott Gottlieb.
sunday shows

Former FDA commissioner questions whether researchers should continue to publish sequences of novel viruses