The Bullpen

Where are the grownups?

In this edition of The Week's editor's letter, William Falk says we can no longer avoid making difficult spending choices 

William Falk

In the past week, there's been a lot of talk of the need for "adult conversations" about government spending, so let's have one about Provenge. That's the name of a new treatment for advanced prostate cancer that federal officials are currently reviewing to see if it will be covered by Medicare and Medicaid. Provenge, a study shows, increases survival for advanced prostate cancer patients — by an average of four months. Its cost: $90,000 for those four months of treatment. Is it worth that much to give a terminally ill person a few more months? It sure as hell is, if it's your life, or that of someone you love. For the hopeless, hope is never too expensive. But as H. Gilbert Welch of the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy told The Washington Post last week, the question becomes more complicated if society has a finite number of health-care dollars to spend. ''That’s $100,000 Medicare can’t spend elsewhere," Welch says. Multiply Provenge by, say, 30,000 patients a year, and you get $2.7 billion. Multiply that by other expensive new cancer therapies, prescription drugs, and other medical treatments, and you get monstrous health-care costs that are swallowing much of our national wealth.

So what do we do? If we impose coldly rational limits on health-care spending, we're engaged in rationing. If we refuse to limit spending on health care — or on Social Security or national defense or education — because such limits will cause distress, suffering, and outrage, then we've decided to keep spending trillions we don't have, endlessly. There's a name for people who won't accept that life is difficult, and that hard choices must be made. We call them children.

More From...

Picture of William FalkWilliam Falk
Read All
The photos we don't see
people visit the memorial set up near the Allen Premium Outlets mall.
Editor's letter

The photos we don't see

The gender wars
a chalkboard with a list of gender pronouns.
Editor's letter

The gender wars

Destroying court credibility
Supreme Court building in New York.
Editor's letter

Destroying court credibility

The worship of weapons
A woman looks up and prays at the Memorial held at The Covenant School after the shooting.
Editor's letter

The worship of weapons

Recommended

South Korean man facing prison time after opening airplane door in midair
An Asiana Airlines flight that had its emergency door opened midair.
Problems in the Sky

South Korean man facing prison time after opening airplane door in midair

Recep Tayyip Erdogan wins re-election in Turkey
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan.
Emerging Victorious

Recep Tayyip Erdogan wins re-election in Turkey

10 things you need to know today: May 28, 2023
The national debt clock in midtown Manhattan.
Daily briefing

10 things you need to know today: May 28, 2023

UK airports facing major delays after passport scanning system fails
A row of shutdown e-passport scanners at London's Gatwick Airport.
Passport Problems

UK airports facing major delays after passport scanning system fails

Most Popular

Disney hits back against DeSantis
Entranceway to Walt Disney World.
Feature

Disney hits back against DeSantis

Censoring ideas and rewriting history
Copies of banned books from various states and school systems.
Briefing

Censoring ideas and rewriting history

What the shifting religious landscape means for American politics
Ballot box
Talking point

What the shifting religious landscape means for American politics