Opinion Brief

Is the Pope another Nixon?

While some commentators are calling the Catholic Church's sex-abuse scandal a "Holy Watergate" — others damn the comparisons as "shameful"

Commentators are drawing parallels between the growing woes of Pope Benedict XVI and the fall of Richard Nixon. Just like Nixon, the Pope has been accused of covering up crimes, has blamed the media, and ignored calls to stand down. Some have even branded this "Watergate with holy water." How valid are these comparisons?

The pope's media attacks certainly echo Nixon: Reducing pervasive sex abuse and pedophilia to "the problem of an overzealous media" is certainly Nixonian, says Jeff Schweitzer in the Huffington Post, The church's "paranoid insularity" causes it to lash out at the press rather than "acknowlege moral failure" at an institutional level, just as in the 1970s White House. "Nixon would be proud." "Vatican chooses to prey on rather than pray for children"

Nixon's crimes were far worse: To compare Nixon and the Pope is "shameful" and wrong, says Marc Thiessen in the Washington Post. The Watergate burglary was ordered by "the highest levels of the Nixon administration." But there is no evidence that Benedict or anyone close to him "personally ordered the molestation of children." These "scurrilous accusations" must stop."Pope Benedict is not like Nixon"

The office of the Pope is not above the law: Just as Nixon believed his office was above the law, says Tom McNichol in the Atlantic, so the Pope relies on his "papal infallability" to avoid dealing with this scandal. But that doctrine only covers "specific matters of dogma," not everything the Pope says or does. If the Church won't admit that, then Benedict could share Nixon's fate – "a long and bitter fight, followed by resignation.""Papalgate: The Pope's Nixon problem"

........................................

PREVIOUS OPINION BRIEFS ON THIS TOPICIs the Catholic Church being persecuted?

Recommended

Joint Chiefs Chair Milley explains why he didn't resign over Afghanistan withdrawal
Mark Milley.
part of the job

Joint Chiefs Chair Milley explains why he didn't resign over Afghanistan withdrawal

The heart of the Evergrande crisis
Xi Jinping.
Picture of Noah MillmanNoah Millman

The heart of the Evergrande crisis

Trump gave order to withdraw all troops from Afghanistan by Jan. 15, Milley confirms
Mark Milley.
milley testifies

Trump gave order to withdraw all troops from Afghanistan by Jan. 15, Milley confirms

New chancellor at Kabul University bans women from campus
An Afghan girl sits in an empty classroom.
going backwards

New chancellor at Kabul University bans women from campus

Most Popular

Jimmy Fallon and Nicole Kidman almost make it through interview without awkwardness
Jimmy Fallon and Nicole Kidman
Last Night on Late Night

Jimmy Fallon and Nicole Kidman almost make it through interview without awkwardness

7 cartoons about America's vaccine fights
Editorial Cartoon.
Feature

7 cartoons about America's vaccine fights

Democrats are governing like Republicans
A donkey.
Picture of W. James Antle IIIW. James Antle III

Democrats are governing like Republicans