First, you hear 'œthe low, mumbling sound of Muslim prayers' from somewhere in the darkness, said Louis Wittig in National Review Online. Then all becomes confusion and terror—passengers and hijackers yelling, frantic flight controllers, bloody stabbings with box cutters. At this point in a recent New York City screening of United 93, some audience members had their hands clamped over their mouths. One of them 'œgroaned sporadically,' got up, 'œstood in the aisle, still transfixed for a few seconds,' and ran away. He didn't see the desperate calls to loved ones, the passengers' uprising, the final plunge to earth. When the lights came up, a World Trade Center survivor rushed for the bathroom to splash cold water on his face. 'œHe muttered 'Wow' several times and said he was still trying to breathe.'
For any American who lived through that awful day, said Stephanie Zacharek in Salon.com, director Paul Greengrass' United 93 is a wrenching experience. On Sept. 11, having learned that terrorists had plunged three hijacked jets into the World Trade Center and the Pentagon, some of the 40 passengers on a fourth plane rebelled and rushed the cockpit, only to die when the plane crashed in a field in Pennsylvania. United 93 is no crass exploitation flick; it's a 'œbrilliantly crafted' tribute that displays 'œalmost boundless sensitivity to persons living and dead.' Yet for all of the film's integrity, it offers 'œno hope of transcendence,' no relief from the nausea and heartache that lingers after you've fled the theater. 'œI've never had a more excruciating moviegoing experience in my life.' I couldn't help but wonder 'œwhy it was made in the first place.'
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
-
How AI is offering journalists protection from persecution in VenezuelaUnder the Radar Media organisations launch news show hosted by AI-generated avatars to 'shelter their real-life journalists'
-
Today's political cartoons - November 17, 2024Cartoons Sunday's cartoons - Trump turkey, melting media, and more
-
5 contentious cartoons about Matt Gaetz's AG nominationCartoons Artists take on ethical uncertainty, offensive justice, and more
-
9 chart-topping hits that stirred controversyIn Depth 'Rich Men North of Richmond' and 'Try That in a Small Town' are the latest musical hits to generate cultural furor
-
The new golf league challenging the PGA, explainedSpeed Read What you need to know about LIV Golf
-
Paul Ryan: Is it racist to blame poverty on culture?feature Paul Ryan sparked outrage when he attributed the cause of poverty in the nations's inner cities to a culture of "men not working.”
-
The GOP: Are party leaders divorcing the Tea Party?
feature It was only a few years ago that the Tea Party movement helped the GOP seize control of the House in the 2010 midterms.
-
The GOP: Is Ted Cruz the new face of the party?
feature The GOP must decide, and decide soon, whether Ted Cruz’s angry, extremist rhetoric will define its message.
-
Tea Party rebellion: Is America still fighting the Civil War?
feature The philosophical and demographic gulf between the two parties has become a chasm, making compromise almost impossible.
-
Fast-food workers: Do they deserve a living wage?
feature Workers at major fast-food chains staged one-day strikes during peak mealtimes to demand an increase in their wages.
-
Trayvon Martin: The meaning of a teen’s tragic death
feature Once again, we have been given heartbreaking proof “of the ongoing peril of being young, black, and male in this country.”
