Thou shalt not mock Tom Cruise. Another month, another "cartoon-blasphemy scandal," said Andrew Sullivan in the London Sunday Times. When a recent episode of Comedy Central’s South Park took aim at Scientology, mocking its space-alien belief system as well as devotees Tom Cruise and John Travolta, "all hell broke loose." Singer and Scientologist Isaac Hayes, who supplied the voice of Chef, announced he could no longer work for a show that "disrespects" people’s "personal spiritual beliefs." Then Comedy Central canceled a repeat of the episode, reportedly after Tom Cruise threatened not to promote the upcoming Paramount picture Mission: Impossible III. (Comedy Central and Paramount are both owned by Viacom.) While it may seem grotesque to compare the flap over one "silly episode of a silly series" to the recent global trauma over the Danish Mohammed cartoons, the principle is the same: A society that doesn’t allow religions to be mocked cannot be considered free.
A noble sentiment, said Pia Catton in The New York Sun. But "this righteous theory of comedy" only works if it’s applied evenhandedly. Last year, South Park took aim at Catholicism, producing a bitterly anti-Catholic episode whose centerpiece was a menstruating Virgin Mary. Outraged Catholic groups demanded the episode be shelved. On that occasion Comedy Central stuck to its guns and refused, nobly citing the cartoonists’ "First Amendment right to poke fun at any and all people." But "where is that tough talk" now? It would seem that Scientology, with its "aging pinup boy" and its other Hollywood connections, has "won a battle that the Catholics could not." What a sorry statement.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
-
The ETA: how new UK travel rules may affect youThe Explainer Full roll-out of Britain's new travel scheme is designed to be easy, but some have already faced problems
-
Arts on prescription: why doctors are prescribing museums and comedyIn The Spotlight Stressed-out patients in Switzerland are being prescribed a trip to the museum to boost their mental wellbeing
-
Shompole Wilderness Camp: reconnect with nature at this secluded retreatThe Week Recommends This luxurious family-run camp in southern Kenya has access to more than 350,000 acres of pristine savannah
