What today's teens miss about the tacky, terrible proms of the 1980s

As I feverishly photographed my son and his friends before their prom, it occurred to me that something was not right. The boys looked as I expected, in black tuxes and combed hair. But the girls were all wrong. Their dresses were simple and flattering. Their make-up was tastefully applied, not caked. The wind blew and their hair actually moved a little.

What the heck? Where was the black eyeliner? Where was the stench of Aqua Net? Where, I must know, were Madonna's lace gloves?

This was not the prom I knew.

Subscribe to The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

When I think of the prom, my frame of reference is 1987. I conjure an image of a me-shaped girl peering out from under a helmet of hair and a mask of make-up. I have to assume that today's girls have been scared straight by their mothers' bad 80s style. They are a sea of good choices, timeless in one tasteful dress after another. These girls will never look back and cringe at their prom photos the way my generation does.

The photographs endure. They turn up like bad pennies over the years, concentrated shots of humility. When I happen upon them, I jump back like I've unearthed White Snake. People say that if you don't like a photograph of yourself, you should wait five years and you'll love it. These people were not photographed in the 1980s.

My hair was styled in a manner that defied both gravity and common decency. The look was achieved with the help of some mousse, a diffuser, and the occasional scrunchi. If my style gurus were Madonna and Einstein, I totally nailed it. Maybe you had a perm, maybe you had bad highlights, maybe you had feathered bangs. If you were me, you had all of them. And you thought it looked pretty darn good.

My dresses seem to have been chosen to compete with my hair. "Look at me," they shouted. "I'm crazy and in bad taste too!" I had a dress that was skin tight and made of red suede, a female Eddie Murphy. I had another that was canary yellow and poofed out at the hips before going straight down, making me look like an anaconda digesting a giraffe. There was a white one, made of lace but somehow also impossibly tight due to a clever use of spandex and netting. The ingenuity that would later create the tech boom was dedicated to prom dress design in the 80s.

The style motto of the 80s was "More is More." Put your makeup on, and then put it on again. If your bracelets aren't stacked all the way up to your elbows, keep 'em coming. Eight or nine rings were standard. I mean, God gave us 10 fingers after all. Our lips were red, our brows were black, and our cheekbones were Pat Benatar razor sharp. I look at these photos and wonder what boy would be brave enough to dance with any of us.

Today's prom goers seem to understand that a teenage girl doesn't need much to look beautiful. Simple hair, a simple dress, and a smile. I mourn the time and dignity we could have saved if we'd known this, too.

The good news is that my friends and I collectively think we look a lot better now than we did on prom night. Not one of us thinks we peaked in high school. What we've lost in collagen, we've gained in judgment. I've got a million photos to prove it.