"Talk about topical," said Sarah Hemming in the Financial Times. The Old Vic must have known that Joe Penhall's "riveting new political drama" would be timely when they programmed it; but what were the odds of it opening three weeks before the election... "well, perhaps best not to talk in betting terms right now".
Marking the return to the stage of James Corden as the titular constituent, this "gripping, comic and, ultimately, moving drama" also boasts an assured performance from Anna Maxwell Martin as a hardworking backbench MP – and landing on stage in the midst of a "mudslinging" scandal, it serves as an important reminder that our politicians are human beings who "conduct their work in an increasingly hostile environment".
The play does not have the "brash polemics" of David Hare, nor the sprawling ambition of James Graham, said Arifa Akbar in The Guardian. Rather, this neat three-hander becomes "universal by being so specific", firmly rooted in the theme of "personal safety versus community responsibility".
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
As Alec, an ex-soldier who served in Afghanistan and who is now about to lose custody of his children, Corden confirms his status as a "great stage actor", said Tim Bano in The Independent. At first, he's "zippy" and fast-talking; later, he moves to the other end of the "emotional spectrum".
Meanwhile, Maxwell Martin delivers a nuanced turn as his MP (and old classmate) who, in trying to help him, gets pulled into a dangerous situation. The scenes play out in "zinging back-and-forths", but the piece feels schematic and underwritten. It's as if we're seeing "two sides of an argument rather than two fully rounded characters – and not just one argument either, but many and scattershot", covering more than enough issues to fill an edition of "Question Time".
I struggled to believe in the third character, said Clive Davis in The Times – a dim-witted police detective; I felt Corden failed to convey the depth of Alec's anguish, and that Matthew Warchus's staging was a bit lacklustre. All told, the evening suffers from "a distinct lack of fireworks".
-
6 sporty homes with tennis courtsFeature Featuring a clay tennis court in New York and a viewing deck in California
-
Critics’ choice: Seafood in the spotlightFeature An experimental chef, a newspaper-worthy newcomer, and a dining titan’s fresh spin-off
-
Taylor Swift’s Showgirl: Much glitter, little goldFeature Swift’s new album has broken records, but critics say she may have gotten herself creatively stuck
-
Theater review: Masquerade218 W. 57th St., New York City 218 W. 57th St., New York City
-
Film reviews: Roofman and Kiss of the Spider WomanFeature An escaped felon’s heart threatens to give him away and a prisoner escapes into daydreams of J.Lo.
-
Broadway actors and musicians are on the brink of a strikeThe explainer The show, it turns out, may not go on
-
Cyrano de Bergerac: a ‘huge-hearted’ productionThe Week Recommends This ‘playful’ and ‘poignant’ rendition brings new life to the ‘gilet-sporting, verse-spouting’ titular soldier
-
I Swear: a ‘warm-hearted’ comedy-dramaThe Week Recommends While ‘inescapably hilarious’, the drama also lifts the lid on John Davidson’s experiences with Tourette syndrome
