A High Court ruling has left government ministers less than a month to find alternative accommodation for the asylum seekers it was housing at The Bell Hotel in Essex. A judge backed Epping Forest District Council's case against the hotel owners for breaching planning rules.
What did the commentators say? If other councils pursue similar cases, it could "throw the government's asylum policy into disarray", said Fiona Parker in The Telegraph. Speaking on the BBC's "Today" programme, Home Office Minister Dan Jarvis (pictured above) said the government was looking at "contingency options" for those staying at The Bell Hotel but refused to name a single one.
The number of asylum seekers in hotels has fallen in recent months to around 32,000, as has the number of hotels being used to house them: currently 210, down from a peak of 402 under the previous Conservative government. But contracts with many of these hotels are in place for another four years.
For a while now, the government has been considering "extensions" to larger asylum seeker sites like Wethersfield, a former RAF base in Essex, said Jack Fenwick at the BBC. Stopping the use of hotels altogether will "save £1 billion", said Chancellor Rachel Reeves in her recent Spending Review, but doing that purely by extending large sites could "anger local residents and refugee-rights groups" alike.
What next? Facilities like Wethersfield have been described as "quasi-detention" because they are "overcrowded and isolated", with "inadequate" access to legal services and healthcare, said academics Giorgia Doná, Charlotte Sanders and Paolo Novak on The Conversation. An alternative could be more "community-based housing", which would require "reviving partnerships between the Home Office and regional and local governments".
The Home Office should begin "consulting more widely locally", as its failure to do so has worsened "community tensions and logistical issues", said Eleanor Langford in The i Paper. Under "renewed pressure", ministers will also look for other ways to "placate the protesters". That could include "ramping up the number and scope" of return agreements, or putting "in motion" some "offshore processing options".
|