“Once scorned by purists as the fake Rolexes of the reading world”, audiobooks are now booming, said Nilanjana Roy in the Financial Times. But questions remain about whether listening to a book instead of poring over its pages counts as reading.
Queen Camilla clearly thinks it does, appearing in cartoon form in a special edition of The Beano comic to tell Dennis the Menace: “Go all in for the National Year of Reading, Dennis! Comics and audiobooks count too!”
‘Pride’ and ‘snobbishness’ Many people don’t think audiobooks “qualify” as proper reading, said Brian Bannon, chief librarian at the New York Public Library, in The New York Times. “There is a pride – even a snobbishness – to being well read.” Telling someone that you’ve listened to a book instead of reading the physical copy often “comes out sounding like an apology”.
Our minds sometimes “wander” both when we’re reading and when listening, David Daniel, a psychology professor at James Madison University in Virginia, told Time. But snapping out of these “little mental sojourns” and finding your place in the text isn’t as easy when you’re listening to a recording, especially when “grappling” with a complex piece of writing.
‘Parallel way to read’ We need to “reframe what it means to be a reader”, moving past the “traditional hierarchical values” that still put physical books at the top, said Debbie Hicks, creative director of the Reading Agency. When it comes to reading, “content” is more important than the “medium”, she told The Guardian.
To suggest that reading books is the “only kind of reading that counts” does a “disservice” to the “many dyslexic or visually challenged booklovers among us”, said Roy in the Financial Times. Audiobooks should be seen as a “parallel way to read”, not dismissed as inferior.
The “destigmatising” of audiobooks could offer a “path to a more nuanced way of thinking about literacy”, said Bannon in The New York Times. “We need more readers – however they get there.” After “struggling to read as a kid, audiobooks were my lifesaver”, said Miranda Larbi in Stylist. They turned out to be a “gateway for physical books – a key for unlocking a world that felt totally inaccessible”.
|