Sex workers' rights vary around the world. The buying and selling of sexual services remains outlawed in many countries, but human rights advocates have criticized criminalization. Now, some countries find ways to embrace the industry through varied legal frameworks.
Legalization In the countries that embrace legalization — like Colombia, Germany, Greece and New Zealand — buying and selling sexual services is both legal and regulated by the government. In some of those places, operating brothels and soliciting sex from a sex worker is also legal. These laws can vary by state or territory: In Australia, it is only fully legal in Queensland, and sex workers must be licensed; Nevada is the only U.S. state with legally regulated sex work.
Abolitionism The most globally prevalent sex work framework is abolitionism, employed in countries like Brazil, India, Thailand, and the UK. Both buying and selling sexual services is legal, but "public solicitation; the operation of brothels; and … pimping, procuring, and forced prostitution are all usually prohibited," the World Population Review said. This approach is the middle ground between criminalization and legalization. Advocates believe governments should allow sex work to occur as long as it does not infringe upon public safety.
Neo-abolitionism Neo-abolitionism is in place in several European countries including France, Sweden and Israel. These laws penalize customers soliciting sexual services. Workers are "considered legally blameless when caught in the act" while clients are prosecuted, said the World Population Review. But many sex workers dislike this model, as having fewer clients means workers have "less freedom to turn down clients we don't want to see, and have to take more risks at work to make up for the loss of income," said sex worker collective Swarm.
Decriminalization Decriminalization calls for the abandonment of laws that prohibit selling, buying and soliciting sexual services. Many human rights organizations believe it's the safest legal approach for workers. It's in place in Australia, Belgium, New South Wales and New Zealand. Criminalizing sex work makes "workers more vulnerable to violence on the job and less likely to report violence," said the American Civil Liberties Union, plus it marginalizes "some of society's most vulnerable groups." |