Fact-checking Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton might be backfiring


Does being told that Hillary Clinton lied when she claimed she landed under sniper fire in Bosnia make you bristle? When people point out that Donald Trump's assertion that Clinton "doesn't do very well with women" is ridiculously incorrect, do you want to prove them wrong? Then you might be guilty of falling under what political scientists call "the backfire effect."
Two such political scientists, Brendan Nyhan and Jason Reifler, put in the time to prove that once someone believes a false statement, trying to show them said statement isn't actually true is incredibly difficult. Nyhan and Reifler's research found that sometimes fact-checking can even make a person more sure of the false statement in question. This is particularly important during election seasons, when supporters of any given candidate have "a tendency to counterargue," as FiveThirtyEight explains. "They draw on the available considerations, malign the source of unwelcome information, and generate ways to buttress the position they are motivated to take. As a result, they can end up becoming surer of their misconceptions," Nyhan said.
In the case of the 2016 race, this is even more likely because "motivated reasoning" flourishes in environments of mistrust — and supporters in both parties have plenty of that. "These are the two most dislikable candidates ever to run — so the temperature is turned up. People on the left say that Trump is a moral abomination and he lies all the time, and you can take these things and imagine someone on the right saying them about Clinton," said Peter Ditto, a psychologist at University of California at Irvine.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
In conclusion, there might be nothing at all you can do to change your uncle's mind about Trump (or your cousin's about Clinton). But if you still want to give it a try, learn about what you're up against at FiveThirtyEight.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
Jeva Lange was the executive editor at TheWeek.com. She formerly served as The Week's deputy editor and culture critic. She is also a contributor to Screen Slate, and her writing has appeared in The New York Daily News, The Awl, Vice, and Gothamist, among other publications. Jeva lives in New York City. Follow her on Twitter.
-
Today's political cartoons - May 10, 2025
Cartoons Saturday's cartoons - artificial intelligence, cryptocurrency, and more
-
5 streetwise cartoons about defunding PBS
Cartoons Artists take on immigrant puppets, defense spending, and more
-
Dark chocolate macadamia cookies recipe
The Week Recommends These one-bowl cookies will melt in your mouth
-
India strikes Pakistan as tensions mount in Kashmir
speed read Pakistan's Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif called it an 'act of war'
-
Israel approves plan to take over Gaza indefinitely
speed read Benjamin Netanyahu says the country is 'on the eve of a forceful entry'
-
Putin talks nukes as Kyiv slated for US air defenses
speed read 'I hope they will not be required,' Putin said of nuclear weapons on Russian state TV
-
US, Ukraine sign joint minerals deal
speed read The Trump administration signed a deal with Ukraine giving the US access to its mineral wealth
-
What happens if tensions between India and Pakistan boil over?
TODAY'S BIG QUESTION As the two nuclear-armed neighbors rattle their sabers in the wake of a terrorist attack on the contested Kashmir region, experts worry that the worst might be yet to come
-
Israel launches air strike on Beirut suburbs
Speed Read The attack targeting Hezbollah was Israel's third on the Lebanese capital since November's ceasefire
-
Dozens dead in Kashmir as terrorists target tourists
Speed Read Visitors were taking pictures and riding ponies in a popular mountain town when assailants open fired, killing at least 26
-
Israel blames 'failures' for killing of medics
speed read 14 Gaza medics and 1 U.N. employee were killed by IDF special forces