“What is the point of the Liberal Democrats?” asked Joanna Williams in The Times. Even those at the party conference seemed unsure: a Lib Dem council leader said the party was “lacking ambition”, while MP Roz Savage wondered why they were “struggling for relevance at precisely the moment when so many people feel powerless”.
During his headlining speech, leader Ed Davey campaigned for an anti-Reform firewall, income tax cuts and a closer proximity to the EU. Yet despite achieving a record number of MPs at the last election, his party is sliding in the polls and, for many members, its blueprint to Westminster appears to be blank.
What did the commentators say? “Younger readers may not believe me, but we used to take the Lib Dems seriously,” said Gareth Roberts in The Spectator. “Or at least more seriously.” We are surrounded by swathes of “repulsive or infuriating politicians”, but Davey is “merely laughable”. There have been calls from within for him to step down, but such is the predicament of the party that these outbursts “hardly seemed to register”.
Davey’s call to rejoin the single market in his closing speech underlines how the party’s strategy is “built on sand”, said Sherelle Jacobs in The Telegraph. Traditionally, the Brexit issue was the “ultimate gift” for the Lib Dems, allowing them to move to the left economically, while profiting as the “right tore itself apart”. But now, the subject ranks “as a fifth-order issue” electorally, so placing it at the core of the party’s agenda “just seems odd”.
Yet if a general election were to be called tomorrow, the Lib Dems would “probably repeat their record-breaking performance of 2024, or get very close”, said Hugo Gye in The Economist. They have “firmly dug in to their core areas”, such as Richmond-upon-Thames, where they won all 54 positions in recent council elections. But it’s difficult to see where the party will go next. “Not everywhere can be Richmond.”
What next? Local elections next year will test whether Davey’s method is working, and a by-election win could help to steady Lib Dem nerves.
|