The White House said this week it will propose a broad overhaul of the National Security Agency’s domestic surveillance program, ending the government’s mass collection of Americans’ call records. Under the plan, records detailing who called whom would remain in the hands of phone companies, and the NSA would need the permission of a judge to review the data for specific searches related to terrorism. A bill before the House Intelligence Committee proposes similar fixes, but would allow the NSA to access phone records prior to a judge’s approval. President Obama touted the reforms as a reasonable compromise that “allows us to do what is necessary to deal with the dangers of a terrorist attack” while protecting privacy.
Don’t believe it, said Trevor Timm in The Guardian (U.K.). Neither the White House plan nor the House bill stops other types of bulk collection, such as mass surveillance of Internet or financial data. These proposals also don’t force the NSA to give up the massive store of data it has already amassed, which no doubt includes information on “millions of innocent people.”
Still, Obama’s plan would “assure Americans that there was some sort of due process going on whenever their phone records are examined by the government,” said Peter Bergen in CNN.com. That brings us closer to the spirit of the Fourth Amendment, which prohibits “unreasonable searches.” And requiring the NSA to get judicial permission is a small price to pay, since a recent study of post-9/11 terror prosecutions in the U.S. showed that the phone-data program “had no discernible impact on preventing acts of terrorism.”
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
Obama and the NSA are not relinquishing surveillance power willingly, said Paul Waldman in WashingtonPost.com. NSA leaker Edward Snowden forced them into it by exposing just how intrusive that power has become. The government’s snoops may have to scale back one way they have of monitoring everyone, “but their desire to keep doing it isn’t going to go away.”
Continue reading for free
We hope you're enjoying The Week's refreshingly open-minded journalism.
Subscribed to The Week? Register your account with the same email as your subscription.
-
10 things you need to know today: October 1, 2023Daily Briefing Government shutdown avoided as Congress passes temporary funding bill, Supreme Court to begin new term as major cases await, and more
-
6 thrilling reads chosen by Ken Follett
Feature The historical novelist suggests works by Frank Herbert, Charles Dickens and more
-
Dress-down democracy
Feature What we lose when we shun suits and ties
-
Putin’s threat to fracture Ukraine
feature Fears that Russia was building a pretext for an invasion of eastern Ukraine grew, as pro-Kremlin protesters occupied government buildings in three cities.
-
Downsizing the military
feature A new budget plan for the Pentagon would save hundreds of billions of dollars by taking the military off its post-9/11 war footing.
-
Putin ratchets up pressure on Ukraine
feature Russian President Vladimir Putin put 150,000 troops at the Ukraine border on high alert and cut off $15 billion in financial aid.
-
Ukraine on the brink of civil war
feature Ukraine’s capital was engulfed in flames and violence when hundreds of riot police launched an assault on an anti-government protest camp.
-
Ukraine at the breaking point
feature An alliance of opposition groups vowed protests would continue until President Viktor Yanukovych is removed from power.
-
Dim prospects for Syrian talks
feature A long-awaited Syrian peace conference in Montreux, Switzerland, quickly degenerated into a cross fire of bitter accusations.
-
The fight over jobless benefits
feature A bill to restore federal benefits for the long-term unemployed advanced when six Republican senators voted with Democrats.
-
Al Qaida’s resurgence in Iraq
feature The Iraqi government was engaged in a ferocious battle with al Qaida–affiliated militants in the western province of Anbar.