Don't Ask, Don't Tell: The end of a policy, the beginning of an idiom

The policy on gays in the military that the Department of Defense instituted in 1993 had four directives: Don't ask, don't tell, don't pursue and don't harass. In the very beginning, it was occasionally referred to as the "don't ask, don't tell, don't pursue" policy, but the name quickly settled into the pithy two-part, four-word expression that we are all familiar with.

"Don't ask, don't tell" fit perfectly into a common English idiom structure, one where two parallel clauses are reduced to their essence in order to make some kind of larger, meaningful statement about the way of the world. Some examples include:

In fact, this is a common idiom structure in other languages as well. Chinese chengyu, for example, are four character expressions like "one day, thousand autumns" (meaning everything is changing so fast, that one day is like a 1,000 years).

Subscribe to The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

The structure has a very satisfying balance to it. It lets you hold two ideas up for inspection in a compact linguistic space. When they are reconciled in that tiny space, a bigger, more complicated idea comes through. "Don't ask, don't tell" became a useful way to say "We will agree to not ask about it and will look the other way, if you agree not to tell us about it, making it impossible for us to pretend we don't know." It has been two years since "don't ask, don't tell" was repealed as a military policy, but it seems to have taken up residence in our storehouse of ready-made expressions for good, which is not surprising, considering how succinctly it captures a common set of circumstances.

Here are eight situations where the idiomatic meaning of the phrase has proved useful:

1. Someone is intentionally looking the other way so as not to be implicated.

As in this article, titled "Dominique Strauss-Kahn has a Don't Ask, Don't Tell Policy Re: Whether a Woman is a Hooker or Not."

Or in this article, asking Whole Foods to end its "don't ask, don't tell" policy about food potentially grown in sewage sludge.

2. Two actors are complicit in getting away with something because neither one is talking about it.

As in this article, claiming President Obama is not talking about jobs because the press is not asking him about jobs.

3. If you know, you're not going to like it, so don't ask.

This recipe for "Don't ask, don't tell" cookies includes sauerkraut as an ingredient. Shhh!

From a post about eating in China:

4. There is information you have a right to know, but it won't be disclosed unless you ask for it.

As in this article about "Don't Ask, Don't Tell Bank Fees."

Or this gaming message board comment: "If I am correct, the gamestop warranty is pretty much a dont ask dont tell thing. Cause i know its that way on xboxs they will replace then for you as long as its within the year"

5. If you can't deal with answers, don't ask the questions.

From an advice column in Men's Fitness:

6. There is a question of whether to disclose information that could be held against you.

Used as a title of articles about telling your employer about dyslexia or depression.

7. There is information you might want to know, but no one has to tell you, even if you ask.

The phrase is used a lot in articles about food labeling where it has been decided that labeling is not required, such as, "FDA: Don't Ask, Don't Tell on Cloned Meat" and "GM Food: Don't Ask, Don't Tell?"

8. General catchall for "looking the other way."

As seen in various random message boards:

...and apparently common in families: