Burning Question

SpaceX: Should we cheer private space flight?

With the first privately-owned spacecraft heading for the International Space Station on May 19, space enthusiasts argue that it's time to stop mourning NASA's decline

On the same day that a teary-eyed NASA crew powered down the last space shuttle, Endeavor, for the last time, the U.S. space agency greenlit the May 19 launch of the shuttle fleet's first private successor, the SpaceX Dragon. If all goes according to plan, the unmanned Dragon cargo capsule will launch atop a SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket, orbit the Earth, then dock at the International Space Station, whose crew will unload the enclosed supplies and send the capsule back for a splash landing off the coast of California. SpaceX, owned by PayPal co-founder Elon Musk, has also announced a partnership with Bigelow Aerospace to shuttle people to inflatable orbiting space capsules — think labs or hotel rooms — as early as 2014. With the SpaceX program, we're "opening a new era in human exploration," says Gizmodo's Jesus Diaz. But how much should we really cheer the dawning "billionaire age" in space travel?

We should all be invested in SpaceX's success: The Dragon is carrying more than tortillas and Tang, says John Harlow in The Australian. It also holds "the hopes of a new generation of billionaire 'space junkies' that private enterprise will now carry forward the torch of exploration lit by NASA" half a century ago. NASA has been fading since the tragic shuttle explosions in 1986 and 2003, and if Musk and his fellow space-obsessed tech titans have their way, they'll use NASA's discarded talent to turn space into "a publicly accessible economic and cultural phenomenon," just like they did with the internet."America's new private space race"

Let's not get ahead of ourselves: The Bigelow deal in particular shows that "the commercial space industry is maturing quickly and has an eye on the future," says Max Eddy at Geekosystem. But "quickly" is a relative term. Eventually, companies like SpaceX will allow "everyday folks to slip the surly bonds of Earth," but we're years, or even decades from accessible space tourism. Getting to space is still expensive and dangerous, and it will take loads of trips financed by the highest bidder before we mere mortals head to the heavens."SpaceX announces partnership with inflatable space station maker..." 

Congress still might mess everything up: NASA is critical to these private companies' success — remember, it's still the biggest client for commercial space travel, says John Kelly in Florida Today. But Congress may still stupidly vote to end the successful competition that NASA is inspiring "among multiple contractors vying to deliver a new, privatized system to carry astronauts to and from the space station." The competition is spawning innovation. But Congress might boneheadedly pick a winner now, which would only ensure future bloat and sloth."Congress could kill rocket builders' new space race"

Recommended

A 'mysterious' bird illness is baffling scientists across parts of the U.S.
European starlings.
Not so fly

A 'mysterious' bird illness is baffling scientists across parts of the U.S.

Why perpetual COVID-19 vaccine boosting 'isn't an ideal option'
Coronavirus vaccine.
solving covid

Why perpetual COVID-19 vaccine boosting 'isn't an ideal option'

Thousands sign petitions to keep Bezos in space
Jeff Bezos.
And stay out

Thousands sign petitions to keep Bezos in space

America's backward climate politics
America on fire.
Picture of Ryan CooperRyan Cooper

America's backward climate politics

Most Popular

Cook called Pelosi with 'warning' about antitrust bills
Tim Cook
mr. cook calls washington

Cook called Pelosi with 'warning' about antitrust bills

7 toons about the Dems' Joe Manchin problem
Political Cartoon.
Feature

7 toons about the Dems' Joe Manchin problem

Bernie Sanders wants to know if cannabis reporter is 'stoned' right now
Bernie Sanders.
Sounds dope

Bernie Sanders wants to know if cannabis reporter is 'stoned' right now