Opinion Brief

9/11 Memorial Merlot: Tasteless?

A Long Island vinter is marketing wine to commemorate the 10th anniversary of the national tragedy — at the jarring price of $19.11 a bottle

A little wine with your remembrance? To coincide with the tenth anniversary of the September 11 tragedy, Lieb Family Cellars, a vintner from Mattituck, Long Island, is producing two varieties of 9/11 Memorial Wine — 9/11 Memorial Commemorative Merlot and 9/11 Memorial Commemorative Chardonnay. The price? A rather on-the-nose $19.11 a bottle. The wine sellers say that 10 percent of each sale will be donated to the National September 11 Memorial and Museum, which initially suggested that the vineyard produce the wine. Is the whole idea too crass?

Yes. This is "utterly tasteless": Ten years later, "we're still struggling to determine what is and is not an appropriate way to remember the tragedy," says Kim Conte at The Stir. But one thing's clear: This wine is just a ploy to "make a buck" off of a national tragedy. The concept makes little sense since uncorking a bottle is typically associated with celebration: "At what point in the day would it be appropriate to break out" the 9/11 vino?
"9/11 memorial wine is utterly tasteless"

Don't get too sour over this: "The link between tacky opportunism and tasteful remembrance is an ever-shifting one," says Mary Elizabeth Williams at Salon. Remember: It was the Memorial Foundation that first approached the winery with this idea — and $8,000 has already been raised. Some people just prefer to give back "with something you can serve with crackers."
"Is a 9/11 wine in bad taste?"

Besides, wine is only the tip of the barrel: Lieb Family Cellars is just one of many companies "jumping on the 9/11 bandwagon," says Abe Sauer at Brand Channel. State Farm and NASCAR will both air commercials tied to the tenth anniversary, while Best Buy is sponsoring a 9/11 Day of Service. Applebee's and gun manufacturer Smith & Wesson will sponsor a commemorative motorcycle ride. "This kind of capitalization may be in overdrive this year, but it is by no means unheard of."
"Brands see Sept. 11 anniversary as opportunity"

Recommended

10 things you need to know today: May 28, 2023
The national debt clock in midtown Manhattan.
Daily briefing

10 things you need to know today: May 28, 2023

White House, Republicans reach tentative debt ceiling deal
President Biden (R) and House Speaker Kevin McCarthy.
Negotiations Complete

White House, Republicans reach tentative debt ceiling deal

10 things you need to know today: May 27, 2023
President Biden speaks to reporters about the debt ceiling.
Daily briefing

10 things you need to know today: May 27, 2023

Ukraine vs. Russia vs. America?
Putin, Biden and Zelenskyy
Talking point

Ukraine vs. Russia vs. America?

Most Popular

Disney hits back against DeSantis
Entranceway to Walt Disney World.
Feature

Disney hits back against DeSantis

Celine Dion cancels tour after neurological disorder diagnosis
Celine Dion
'sorry to disappoint'

Celine Dion cancels tour after neurological disorder diagnosis

1st Jan. 6 sedition sentences land Oath Keepers in prison for 18 and 12 years
Stewart Rhodes
Capitol Siege Aftermath

1st Jan. 6 sedition sentences land Oath Keepers in prison for 18 and 12 years