Best Column

Why 'Mad Men' is one of the worst shows on TV

AMC's hit show suffers from bad writing, preposterous plotting, and amateurish acting, declares Daniel Mendelsohn at The New York Review of Books

Since it premiered in 2007, "Mad Men" has never suffered for critical acclaim. The AMC drama has consistently earned plaudits — not to mention 13 Emmys — for its glossy, meticulous depiction of New York's circa-1960s advertising world. But despite the series' reputation for intelligence, not every member of the intelligentsia is such a big a fan. Writing at The New York Review of Books, author Daniel Mendelsohn contends that the show's  "delirious" critical reaction is completely undeserved. "Melodramatic" story lines make it nothing more than a "soap opera," while its "attitude toward the past is glib...." Here, an excerpt:

"When people talk about the show, they talk (if they’re not talking about the clothes and furniture) about the special perspective its historical setting creates—the graphic picture that it is able to paint of the attitudes of an earlier time, attitudes likely to make us uncomfortable or outraged today. An unwanted pregnancy, after all, had different implications in 1960 than it does in 2011.

To my mind, the picture is too crude and the artist too pleased with himself. In 'Mad Men,' everyone chain-smokes, every executive starts drinking before lunch, every man is a chauvinist pig, every male employee viciously competitive and jealous of his colleagues, every white person a reflexive racist (when not irritatingly patronizing). It's not that you don't know that, say, sexism was rampant in the workplace before the feminist movement; it's just that, on the screen, the endless succession of leering junior execs and crude jokes and abusive behavior all meant to signal 'sexism' doesn't work—it's wearying rather than illuminating."

Read the entire article at The New York Review of Books.

Recommended

The daily gossip: June 11, 2021
Kim and Kanye.
Daily gossip

The daily gossip: June 11, 2021

The revenge of the sitcom wife
Annie Murphy.
Opinion

The revenge of the sitcom wife

The daily gossip: June 10, 2021
Prince Harry.
Daily gossip

The daily gossip: June 10, 2021

The daily gossip: June 9, 2021
Kanye West.
Daily gossip

The daily gossip: June 9, 2021

Most Popular

7 toons about the Dems' Joe Manchin problem
Political Cartoon.
Feature

7 toons about the Dems' Joe Manchin problem

10 things you need to know today: June 11, 2021
Biden and Boris at G7
Daily briefing

10 things you need to know today: June 11, 2021

Texas governor claims Texas will build its own border wall
Greg Abbott
Abbott's Wall

Texas governor claims Texas will build its own border wall