Feature

Chas Freeman and the ‘Israel Lobby’

The withdrawal of Obama’s choice for chief intelligence analyst

A “ferocious” debate over the alleged power of “the Israel Lobby” raged in 2006, after two professors wrote a book of the same name, said the Los Angeles Times in an editorial. The furor re-erupted when President Obama picked former Ambassador Charles (Chas) Freeman to head the National Intelligence Council. He withdrew Tuesday, blaming what he called the dishonorable and dishonest “tactics of the Israel Lobby.”

Not the Israel Lobby “conspiracy theory” again, said The Washington Post in an editorial. Freeman—who said the Chinese should have crushed the Tiananmen Square protesters sooner and offered “sycophantic paeans” to Saudi King Abdullah—was always a bad choice. But his “crackpot” departing “screed” against the mythical “shadowy and sinister ‘Lobby’” made it clear how bad.

Anti-China and, yes, pro-Israel lobbyists did sink Freeman, said David Broder in The Washington Post. And they deprived us of a very able and “smart as hell” intelligence analyst. Freeman’s abrupt pullout is an embarrassment for Obama and for his intelligence chief, Adm. Dennis Blair, who picked and defended Freeman, but it’s also “the country’s loss.”

Freeman is indeed very capable, and his critics did use his statements out of context, “in some cases wildly so,” said Fred Kaplan in Slate. But Obama was right to cut him loose. Freeman was a polarizing distraction, and by his own choice a high-profile figure. The NIC should be neither. Fairly or not, he would have been a “lightning rod” for Obama’s foreign-policy critics.

Recommended

Iran claims to have built its first hypersonic missile
The Fattah missile unveiled by Iran.
Iranian Weaponry

Iran claims to have built its first hypersonic missile

Ukraine blames Russia for destroying major Dnipro River dam 'in panic'
Kakhovka Dam
Cui bono?

Ukraine blames Russia for destroying major Dnipro River dam 'in panic'

Why is Riyadh going it alone on oil cuts?
An illustrated image of oil rigs and oil barrels
Today's big question

Why is Riyadh going it alone on oil cuts?

Officials suspect dozens of girls in Afghanistan were poisoned at school
Girls in Afghanistan walk to school.
awful

Officials suspect dozens of girls in Afghanistan were poisoned at school

Most Popular

Can Chris Christie make a comeback?
A black and white photo of Chris Christie waving
Profile

Can Chris Christie make a comeback?

Is Trump's wall working?
International Border Wall Between Tecate California and Tecate Mexico.
Briefing

Is Trump's wall working?

Orlando's Gay Days draws LGBTQ crowds to Disney World amid DeSantis feud
Gay Days at Walt Disney World in 2023
Come as You Are

Orlando's Gay Days draws LGBTQ crowds to Disney World amid DeSantis feud