Feature

Attorney general: Holder’s pardon problem

Is Eric Holder too tarnished by his role in the pardon of Marc Rich to become attorney general?

So much for Barack Obama’s promise to bring “real change” to Washington, said John Fund in The Wall Street Journal. In nominating Eric Holder to be his attorney general, Obama has reached back for a badly tarnished figure from the Clinton administration. As Clinton’s deputy attorney general, Holder reviewed—and signed off on—the then-president’s sleazy pardon of fugitive financier Marc Rich, who had fled to Switzerland rather than face charges of tax evasion and racketeering connected with illegal oil trades with Iran. Rich’s pardon was greased by his lawyer, former Clinton White House Counsel Jack Quinn, and by a $450,000 donation from Rich’s ex-wife to Clinton’s presidential library. When the pardon request landed on his desk, Holder sent it straight to the White House, saying he was “neutral, leaning towards favorable” on it. “These four words have stalked him since,” said Richard Cohen in The Washington Post, because they suggest Holder “could not say no to power.” As Alberto Gonzales has proved, that’s not a good trait in an attorney general.

You’ve got the Rich story all wrong, said Seth Lipsky in The New York Times, and therefore are giving Holder a bum rap. The financial scheme that landed Rich in trouble in 1983 was an attempt to move his oil profits beyond the reach of the IRS—“the kind of transfer pricing dispute” that belonged in civil court. Indeed, in 1989, the feds ended the use of criminal racketeering charges in similar cases. And don’t discount the foreign-policy agenda behind the pardon, which was issued during sensitive negotiations between Israelis and Palestinians. Rich had strong support in Israel, and President Clinton was using carrots as well as sticks to induce concessions from both sides. Rich’s case falls well within the president’s pardon power.

It certainly fits within the “filthy, venal sleaze” that is typical of Washington, said Glenn Greenwald in Salon.com. The key to the whole sordid affair, according to several New York Times stories, is a 1998 corporate dinner at which Holder sat next to a public relations executive who represented Rich. When the executive asked how Rich should pursue a pardon, Holder pointed out Jack Quinn, who was conveniently across the room. After Rich followed Holder’s insider advice and hired Quinn, “everything magically happened for him.” In his campaign, Obama promised to “delouse” Washington. But how can he change the culture if he surrounds himself with the same corrupt establishment that has “ruined everything it’s touched”?

Recommended

Spanish Prime Minister and U.S. Embassy latest targets in series of letter bombs
U.S. embassy in Madrid
intercepted

Spanish Prime Minister and U.S. Embassy latest targets in series of letter bombs

What is a 'lady-in-waiting,' anyway?
Camilla, King Charles, and Lady Susan Hussey.
the more you know

What is a 'lady-in-waiting,' anyway?

Paul Whelan reportedly moved to prison hospital
Paul Whelan.
that's concerning

Paul Whelan reportedly moved to prison hospital

A brief history of Pakistan's recent political turmoil
Imran Khan.
Briefing

A brief history of Pakistan's recent political turmoil

Most Popular

GOP leader Kevin McCarthy's bid for House speaker may really be in peril
Kevin McCarthy
You don't have the votes

GOP leader Kevin McCarthy's bid for House speaker may really be in peril

World's 1st hydrogen-powered jet engine could mark turning point for aviation industry
A Rolls-Royce engine seen during an airshow.
Flying High

World's 1st hydrogen-powered jet engine could mark turning point for aviation industry

U.S. gas prices fall to pre–Ukraine invasion levels
Gas station
Gas Holiday

U.S. gas prices fall to pre–Ukraine invasion levels