Shed no tears for Sarah Heath Palin, said John Heilemann in New York. Alaska’s telegenic governor will not be our next vice president, but this week’s defeat has cleared her way to a bigger prize. Palin’s sudden, surprise emergence onto the national stage “electrified the Republican grass roots as no candidate has in years,” and left many evangelicals and rural conservatives convinced that she’s the “next-generation XX-chromosome Ronald Reagan” who can lead them to victory in 2012. Palin has her detractors even within the party, said Fred Barnes in The Weekly Standard. But once the dust has settled from 2008, and the GOP searches for a nominee with the “middle-class magnetism” to win a general election, they may come to realize “the enormous asset they have in Palin.” As a serious Christian, mother of five, and “fearless slayer of (male) political bigwigs,” she has convinced heartland conservatives that she’s “one of them.”
There’s no disputing Sarah Palin’s “rock star quality,” said Jerry Zremski in The Buffalo News. The problem is that she’s a rock star in the mold of “Pat Benatar—popular with her fans, but not with a legion of critics.” Beneath the charisma, said Peter Beinart in The Washington Post, Palin’s “brand is culture war.” She preaches the us-against-them mentality of the Republican base, not the kind of message that wins you a national majority. In the campaign just ended, Palin’s divisiveness cost McCain votes with moderates and independents, perhaps even the election itself. In 2012, Palin’s tribalism will be an even tougher sell to a nation that’s turned its back on the rancor and nastiness of the Clinton and Bush years. Some desperate Republicans may look at Palin and see the future, but the rest of us see a creature of the past, the “last of the culture warriors.”
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
