What happened
Karl Rove, President Bush's closest and longest-serving advisor, announced this week that he would resign at the end of the month. One of the most controversial figures in American politics, Rove was instrumental in shaping both policy decisions and Republican campaign strategies. 'œI'm grateful to have been a witness to history,' said Rove, appearing with Bush outside the White House. Rove, nicknamed 'œthe architect' by Bush and 'œBush's brain' by his critics, said he wanted to spend more time with his family and write a book about Bush's presidency. He has been by Bush's side since 1993, when Bush first ran for governor of Texas.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
What the editorials said
Love him or hate him, said The Hartford Courant, Rove has 'œa record of success that puts his contemporaries to shame.' In 2000, he helped Bush defeat a charismatic war hero, John McCain, in the primaries, and a sitting vice president, Al Gore, in the general election. In 2002, he engineered the Republican takeover of Congress. And in 2004, he shocked Democrats who thought they had Bush on the ropes. 'œIn large part due to his genius, the Republican Party came closer to being a majority governing party than it had been in some 70 years.'
But his fatal mistake, said The Boston Globe, was using 'œthe same take-no-prisoners techniques in governing.' Rove's agenda was never just to win elections. He wanted to ensure a permanent Republican majority. But his strategy backfired. Instead of working with the other side on issues such as Social Security and immigration, he tried to steamroll the opposition as if he were running another campaign. As a result, he leaves an administration with 'œa meager legacy' of policy accomplishments.
What the columnists said
Cut Rove some slack, said Fred Barnes in The Weekly Standard. For years, Democrats believed he was the boogeyman who secretly orchestrated every Republican success. Now Republicans want to blame him for all their failures. But 'œpolitical advisors like Rove offer advice, not magic.' Bush's agenda stalled because his popularity dipped, largely due to of Iraq. 'œRove's career demonstrates two things: the important role a strategist can play and the sharp limits on what even the best of the bunch can accomplish.'
Actually, the damage this man has inflicted can't be overstated, said Andrew Sullivan in The Atlantic Online. The nub of Rove's approach was 'œdivide and conquer,' which may work in campaigns, but is poison as a governing philosophy. After 9/11, Americans were ripe to be united. But Rove took this historic opportunity and 'œthrew it away in a binge of hate-filled niche campaigning, polarization, and short-term expediency.'
It's unfair to blame Rove for polarizing American politics, said Rich Lowry in the New York Post. 'œBush had become a hate figure on the left' starting with the 2000 Florida voting controversy. But if the administration's tough response to 9/11 divided the country, that's what comes from leadership under difficult circumstances. And if Rove played a key role in shaping that response, then he served his nation well.
What next?
The New York Times
-
August 10 editorial cartoonsCartoons Sunday's political cartoons include a global plastics problem, GOP enthusiasm over tariffs, and more
-
5 thin-skinned cartoons about shooting the messengerCartoons Artists take on unfavorable weather, a look in the mirror, and more
-
Is Trump's new peacemaking model working in DR Congo?Talking Point Truce brokered by the US president in June is holding, but foundations of a long-term peace have let to be laid
-
A bipartisan deal on the federal budgetfeature House and Senate negotiators overcame partisan divisions to hammer out a budget deal, but it remained unclear whether it would be approved.
-
The furor over U.S. wiretapping of its allies
feature The president faced a full-scale diplomatic crisis after leaked documents revealed that the NSA had for years tapped the cellphone of Angela Merkel.
-
The Weiner scandal, Part 2
feature Anthony Weiner acknowledged that he had continued to send sexually explicit messages online after resigning from Congress in disgrace.
-
The IRS’s Tea Party crackdown
feature The Obama administration was scrambling to distance itself from a growing scandal at the Internal Revenue Service.
-
A strong start for holiday sales
feature Shoppers flocked to malls and spent record sums online over the Thanksgiving weekend.
-
Anti-American riots spread
feature A violent backlash against a U.S.-made film that mocked the Prophet Mohammed continued to sweep across the Muslim world.
-
Bishops sue over birth control
feature More than 40 Catholic institutions filed lawsuits challenging the new health-care law's mandate for birth control coverage.
-
Seeking facts in the Martin case
feature The parents of Trayvon Martin called for federal officials to investigate the prosecutor who decided not to charge their son’s killer.