What happened
Standing for the first time before a ConÂgress controlled by Democrats, a conciliatory President Bush this week offered a modest agenda of domestic initiatives and appealed for bipartisan cooperation. In his State of the Union address, Bush proposed a plan to cut projected gasoline consumption by 20 percent over 10 years and boost production of alternative fuels, particularly ethanol. He also asked Congress to create a new standard deduction for health insurance that would reward individuals for buying their own insurance and enable the uninsured to buy coverage. With California Democrat Nancy Pelosi, the first female House speaker, sitting behind him, he asked Democrats to join him in tackling such problems as immigration and education. 'œOur citizens don't much care which side of the aisle we sit on,' he said, 'œas long as we are willing to cross that aisle when there is work to be done.'
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
What the editorials said
'œWhere was this Bush a year ago?' asked National Review Online. His 'œsolid case for victory in Iraq' made the Democrats look like the defeatists they are, and he offered a 'œgenuinely innovative' plan on health insurance. But the Democrats contemptuously brushed aside his proposals, and with polls showing Bush's approval ratings down to the low 30s, they may get away with it. 'œThe president is down, way down, and the State of the Union address is not going to do anything to change that.'
Especially not this address, said the Los Angeles Times. The president attempted to show a Democratic-controlled Congress and a disillusioned public that he is still a political force to be reckoned with. But he made an unconvincing case, offering a domestic agenda that was either recycled from previous speeches or, in the case of health care, a cautious echo of bolder proposals by some state governors. Bush knows he's negotiating from weakness, which may be why he 'œseemed at times to be going through the motions.'
What the columnists said
To save what's left of his presidency, said John Dickerson in Slate.com, Bush needed to hit a home run. 'œYet he did nothing in his speech to change the political dynamic.' He asked for bipartisanship, but despite a brief mention of 'œglobal climate change,' offered nothing surprising or daring. He was especially uncompromising on Iraq. By nakedly pressuring Congress to get behind the troop increase—or else—'œhe undermines his efforts to reach out.'
The Democrats came off no better, said Ruth Marcus in The Washington Post. They reflexively brushed aside a health-care proposal with real merit, which would pay for covering the uninsured by raising taxes on 'œthe well-off.' But the president invited this kind of partisan reaction. After six years of being treated with 'œpoisonous' disdain, 'œDemocrats would be crazy if their instinctive reaction' to any Bush proposal was anything but deep suspicion.
Let's not forget that we're at war, said John Podhoretz in the New York Post. Democrats have a responsibility to the nation, and Bush graciously offered them a chance to support 'œthe most critical struggle of our time.' Most Democrats declined the invitation, sitting on their hands when the president called for victory in Iraq. They seem to think a war-weary populace won't punish them for their defeatism. For the nation's sake, I hope they're wrong.
What next?
-
The 5 best singers turned actors of all timethe week recommends It's not often that someone is born with both of these rare skill sets
-
'This is exactly what technology should be doing'Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
-
Black women are being pushed out of the workforce en masseIN THE SPOTLIGHT Employment data shows hundreds of thousands of Black women have left the labor market over the past few months. What's behind this mass exodus?
-
A bipartisan deal on the federal budgetfeature House and Senate negotiators overcame partisan divisions to hammer out a budget deal, but it remained unclear whether it would be approved.
-
The furor over U.S. wiretapping of its allies
feature The president faced a full-scale diplomatic crisis after leaked documents revealed that the NSA had for years tapped the cellphone of Angela Merkel.
-
The Weiner scandal, Part 2
feature Anthony Weiner acknowledged that he had continued to send sexually explicit messages online after resigning from Congress in disgrace.
-
The IRS’s Tea Party crackdown
feature The Obama administration was scrambling to distance itself from a growing scandal at the Internal Revenue Service.
-
A strong start for holiday sales
feature Shoppers flocked to malls and spent record sums online over the Thanksgiving weekend.
-
Anti-American riots spread
feature A violent backlash against a U.S.-made film that mocked the Prophet Mohammed continued to sweep across the Muslim world.
-
Bishops sue over birth control
feature More than 40 Catholic institutions filed lawsuits challenging the new health-care law's mandate for birth control coverage.
-
Seeking facts in the Martin case
feature The parents of Trayvon Martin called for federal officials to investigate the prosecutor who decided not to charge their son’s killer.