A Showdown over Iraq’s Proposed Constitution
The constitution’s drafted, but the vote will be delayed.
What happened
Iraq's Shiite Muslim majority and independence-minded Kurds submitted a draft constitution this week but delayed a vote beyond a Monday deadline, hoping to coax angry Sunni Muslims into dropping their objections. The proposal would reshape Iraq as a loose federal union with Islam as the official state religion, with a prohibition on any civil law contradicting Islamic teachings. Sunnis said that such a system would lead to the breakup of Iraq by letting Shiites form a massive autonomous region in the south, home to the country's largest oil fields. If the proposal is enacted, said Saleh Mutlak, a Sunni delegate, 'œthe streets will rise up.'
Shiites and Kurds sought to allay Sunni fears by promising them a share of the nation's oil wealth. But the structure of the new government is non-negotiable, said Humam Hamoudi, the Shiite chairman of the constitutional committee, and each of the country's three major ethnic and religious groups will be given a large measure of self-rule. 'œThere will be no central government like before,' Hamoudi said.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
What the editorials said
At last there is 'œreason for optimism' in Iraq, said the Chicago Tribune. The Kurds and the Shiites, who represent 80 percent of Iraq's population, have reached a 'œthreshold that doubters had said they could not possibly cross this quickly.' The 'œobstructionist Sunnis' must choose. They can reject the constitution 'œor they can reluctantly get on board, acknowledging that they don't want the future to leave without them.'
The Sunnis aren't the only ones who are disappointed, said The New York Times. This 'œbadly flawed' document 'œdoes little to advance the prospects for a unified and peaceful Iraq,' and threatens basic freedoms for Iraq's women, such as property rights and equality in marriage. The Bush administration has been trying to justify the war by claiming it will establish Iraq as a beacon of democracy in the Arab world. Now, Bush seems willing to settle for a budding Shiite theocracy. 'œAmericans continue dying in Iraq, but their mission creeps steadily downward.'
What the columnists said
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
You call this a constitution? said Fred Kaplan in Slate.com. It's a hopelessly 'œvague' document, riddled with contradictions. It has clauses that say, for example, that both Islamic law and democracy will be respected. 'œSo, which clause takes precedence?' And while it guarantees Sunnis a share of oil wealth extracted from 'œcurrent wells,' it cuts them out of reserves tapped in the future. Whether this fuzzy document is 'œrammed through' or is rejected, it is not at all clear 'œwhat kind of government, what kind of nation, this war and this process have wrought.'
Shiite leaders may be taking the country 'œinto the abyss,' said Spencer Ackerman in The New Republic Online. Sunnis will surely try to muster the votes to defeat the constitution at the polls. If they succeed, the government will fall and Iraq will be thrust into chaos. But if they fail, the insurgency will likely bloom into an open Sunni rebellion. 'œRepressing that rebellion will surely take Iraq—and U.S. troops—to new levels of bloodshed with no clear endpoint.'
Only one endpoint is worth contemplating, said William Kristol in The Weekly Standard. Victory. Every step Iraq takes toward democracy and stability marks one more battle won on 'œthe central front in the war on terror—our war on terror.' It could take a few years yet for a new Iraqi government to stand up, and for a new Iraqi army to become strong enough to replace U.S. forces. If defeating the insurgency means that we have to 'œstay and fight side-by-side with the Iraqis,' so be it.
What next?
The Week
-
Can AI tools be used to Hollywood's advantage?
Talking Points It makes some aspects of the industry faster and cheaper. It will also put many people in the entertainment world out of work
By Anya Jaremko-Greenwold, The Week US Published
-
'Paraguay has found itself in a key position'
Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
By Justin Klawans, The Week US Published
-
Meet Youngmi Mayer, the renegade comedian whose frank new memoir is a blitzkrieg to the genre
The Week Recommends 'I'm Laughing Because I'm Crying' details a biracial life on the margins, with humor as salving grace
By Scott Hocker, The Week US Published
-
Putin’s threat to fracture Ukraine
feature Fears that Russia was building a pretext for an invasion of eastern Ukraine grew, as pro-Kremlin protesters occupied government buildings in three cities.
By The Week Staff Last updated
-
Curbing NSA surveillance
feature The White House said it will propose a broad overhaul of the National Security Agency’s domestic surveillance program.
By The Week Staff Last updated
-
Downsizing the military
feature A new budget plan for the Pentagon would save hundreds of billions of dollars by taking the military off its post-9/11 war footing.
By The Week Staff Last updated
-
Putin ratchets up pressure on Ukraine
feature Russian President Vladimir Putin put 150,000 troops at the Ukraine border on high alert and cut off $15 billion in financial aid.
By The Week Staff Last updated
-
Ukraine on the brink of civil war
feature Ukraine’s capital was engulfed in flames and violence when hundreds of riot police launched an assault on an anti-government protest camp.
By The Week Staff Last updated
-
Ukraine at the breaking point
feature An alliance of opposition groups vowed protests would continue until President Viktor Yanukovych is removed from power.
By The Week Staff Last updated
-
Dim prospects for Syrian talks
feature A long-awaited Syrian peace conference in Montreux, Switzerland, quickly degenerated into a cross fire of bitter accusations.
By The Week Staff Last updated
-
The fight over jobless benefits
feature A bill to restore federal benefits for the long-term unemployed advanced when six Republican senators voted with Democrats.
By The Week Staff Last updated