Feature

Iraqis sue Blackwater

Iraqis filed a U.S. lawsuit against Blackwater USA over a deadly shootout. It’s “unclear” whether a judge will let this lawsuit go anywhere, said Spencer Ackerman in TalkingPointsMemo’s Muckraker. Despite all the handwringing, said James Pinkerton in News

What happenedA lawyer for families of a survivor and three Iraqi civilians killed in a Sept. 16 Baghdad shootout filed a lawsuit against Blackwater USA on Thursday, saying the security firm has “fostered a cowboy culture” in Iraq. Blackwater has said its guards fired in self-defense, and a spokeswoman said the company would fight the lawsuit “vigorously.”

What the commentators saidIt’s “unclear” whether a judge will let this lawsuit go anywhere, said Spencer Ackerman in TalkingPointsMemo’s Muckraker. There’s no precedent giving Iraqis standing to sue military contractors in U.S. courts. But the case could force Blackwater’s lawyers to disclose “documents substantiating all sorts of rumored misdeeds,” which would make the case significant even if it gets tossed out of court.

The only legal remedy for the plaintiffs might be in Iraq, said Allison J. Rubin and Paul von Zielbauer in The New York Times (free registration). There’s a “clear body of law” to indicate whether charges are appropriate when U.S. soldiers fire on civilians, but only “untested” legal theories about what to do when private security contractors do the shooting. But the State Department could give the families their day in court by waiving “immunity for contractors” and letting “the case be tried in the Iraqi courts.”

All the handwringing over Blackwater ignores an important point, said James P. Pinkerton in Newsday. This kind of gray area is exactly “what America wanted.” Most “voters have generally supported the decades-long bipartisan trend toward governmental downsizing, ‘reinvention’ and outright privatization.” Besides, when we trudge into “murky situations around the world,” we need to “deploy shadowy companies” so we don’t get “the Stars and Stripes” too dirty.

Recommended

France says it killed ISIS Africa leader in 'decisive blow against this terrorist group'
France announces ISIS death
ISIS

France says it killed ISIS Africa leader in 'decisive blow against this terrorist group'

Australians think Biden forgot their prime minister's name at nuclear-sub event
Scott Morrison and Joe Biden
'that fellow Down Under'

Australians think Biden forgot their prime minister's name at nuclear-sub event

U.S. to share nuclear submarine technology with Australia
President Biden.
global security

U.S. to share nuclear submarine technology with Australia

Lindsey Graham boosts Afghanistan's anti-Taliban resistance behind the scenes
Lindsey Graham.
get the word out

Lindsey Graham boosts Afghanistan's anti-Taliban resistance behind the scenes

Most Popular

Emmys host Cedric the Entertainer hoping 'not to get canceled'
Leon Bennett/Getty Images
'what have I done in the last three months'

Emmys host Cedric the Entertainer hoping 'not to get canceled'

Did Theranos Lose Afghanistan?
Elizabeth Holmes and James Mattis.
Samuel Goldman

Did Theranos Lose Afghanistan?

How Newsom ran away with the recall
Gavin Newsom.
Picture of David FarisDavid Faris

How Newsom ran away with the recall