‘Theatre of cruelty’: has the reality TV bubble burst?
A million fewer viewers watched the latest Love Island launch compared to last year
The era of reality TV has seen countless viewers tuning into shows such as “Big Brother” and birthed household names, brands and sponsorships.
But after years of headline-grabbing on-screen exploits by would-be and established stars alike, latest rating figures suggest the genre’s popularity may be in terminal decline. The return of the latest series of “Love Island” on ITV2 was watched live by 1.3 million people – more than a million down on the last summer launch.
The steep drop follows a steady decline in the show’s popularity in recent years, amid growing concern about the real-life impacts of reality TV. So do the likes of “Love Island” still have a place in 2023, asked The Independent’s culture reporter Isobel Lewis,or have they “finally given us the ick?”
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
‘Theatre of cruelty’
Debate about show producers’ duty of care to the people involved in reality TV has been growing since former “Love Island” presenter Caroline Flack took her own life in 2020.
As problematic ethical issues surrounding the show “spilled over the villa’s walls and out into the real world”, said Lewis in The Independent, it became increasingly clear that “the fun wasn’t as harmless as it seemed”. Charities joined in warnings about gaslighting and emotional abuse, both on screen and on social media feeds about participants.
Reality TV is “brain-rotting at best”, warned author and cultural commentator Iona David in The Guardian. The genre “can negatively affect the societal code of acceptable behaviour” and “at worst, it is lethal”.
Britain’s reality shows, in particular, are a “theatre of cruelty”, said The New York Times after “The Jeremy Kyle Show” was pulled from ITV in 2019 following the death of a guest who was humiliated on air. These programmes are “designed to demonise” and “make us despise” those who take part, the paper argued, but “someone had to die” for action to be taken.
In the wake of such scandals, ITV and the BBC have vowed to take their duty of care more seriously. Measures introduced to safeguard the latest “Love Island” contestants include social media trainer, psychological support and behaviour and relationship training. Participants are also banned from banned using social media during the series to shield themselves and their families from online abuse.
Questions remain about whether enough has been done, however.
Viewers once yearned for “gory spectacles of humiliation and occasionally violence”, said Sirin Kale on Vice last year. But as they have “lost their taste for blood”, show producers have “faced a seemingly irreconcilable tension: between making a show entertaining, and making it ethical”.
As producers struggle to win back audiences, the age of the reality TV superstar may already be drawing to a close.
Last year’s “Love Island” winner Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu secured a deal worth a rumoured £1 million with fashion brand Oh Polly after appearing on the show. But the Daily Mail reported earlier this year that the reality star had been dropped, because the partnership “wasn’t working”.
“Gone are the days of the million pound Islander,” brand and culture expert Nick Ede told the paper.
‘An evolution’
Although reality TV shows such as “Love Island” are suffering ratings decline, some newcomers to the genre are flourishing.
Reality competition series “The Traitors” was applauded as “the most exquisite reality TV of the year” by The Guardian’s Rebecca Nicholson after debuting in December. The show “feels like a revival of the early, more innocent days” of the genre, she wrote.
Later this year, perhaps the most famous reality TV show ever, “Big Brother”, will return in a highly anticipated ITV reboot. The show “laid the foundations” for the genre, said Gwilym Mumford in the same paper. And the new series could be the “antidote to many of the genre’s current issues”.
Despite these many ongoing problems, said Kale on Vice, “it’s unlikely we’ll see the end of reality TV”. This type of entertainment is “too profitable, too sprawling, too entrenched”.
“What we’ll see instead,” she predicted, “is an evolution of the genre into something kinder, less exploitative, and more resonant with our progressive, mental-health aware times”.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
Rebekah Evans joined The Week as newsletter editor in 2023 and has written on subjects ranging from Ukraine and Afghanistan to fast fashion and "brotox". She started her career at Reach plc, where she cut her teeth on news, before pivoting into personal finance at the height of the pandemic and cost-of-living crisis. Social affairs is another of her passions, and she has interviewed people from across the world and from all walks of life. Rebekah completed an NCTJ with the Press Association and has written for publications including The Guardian, The Week magazine, the Press Association and local newspapers.
-
Saint Paul de Vence: a paradise for art lovers
The Week Recommends The hilltop gem in the French Riviera where 20th century modernism flourished
By Alexandra Zagalsky Published
-
'People in general want workers to earn a decent living'
Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
By Justin Klawans, The Week US Published
-
What might a Trump victory mean for the global economy?
Today's Big Question A second term in office for the 'America First' administration would send shockwaves far beyond the United States' shores
By Rafi Schwartz, The Week US Published
-
'Beast' of a lawsuit: YouTube star and Amazon sued by contestants over abuse claims
The Explainer Can the breakout YouTube star weather a growing scandal engulfing his forthcoming reality TV competition?
By Rafi Schwartz, The Week US Published
-
Netflix's real-life Squid Game: 'reality epic' or 'shoddy knock-off'?
Talking Point 456 players battle it out for the biggest prize pot in reality TV history
By The Week UK Published
-
The Greatest Show Never Made review: stranger than fiction
The Week Recommends An oddly uplifting documentary about people being duped into joining a fake TV series
By Arion McNicoll, The Week UK Published
-
Inside the rocky marriage of Priscilla Presley and Elvis
Under the Radar Rock and roll legend’s former wife praises Sofia Coppola’s new biopic
By Keumars Afifi-Sabet Published
-
How Burning Man descended into chaos
Under the Radar Torrential rain leaves thousands of revellers stuck at Nevada festival
By Chas Newkey-Burden Published
-
Princess Diana’s death in The Crown: how accurate is the Netflix series?
Under the Radar The controversial show is returning for sixth and final season later this year
By Felicity Capon Published
-
Michael Parkinson: five best interviews by star presenter
Under the Radar ‘King of the chat show’ Parky has died aged 88
By Harriet Marsden Published
-
The Beanie Bubble: the true story behind fallen toy empire film
Under the Radar New release depicts rise and fall of 1990s stuffed plushy phenomenon
By Harriet Marsden Published