“It was with a huge sense of trepidation” that I tuned into BBC One’s new four-part drama “Best Interests”, said Nick Hilton in The Independent. Written by Jack Thorne, it tells the harrowing story of a couple who must decide whether doctors should keep treating their desperately unwell daughter.
Nicci (Sharon Horgan) and Andrew (Michael Sheen) have dedicated the past decade to caring for 13-year-old Marnie, who has muscular dystrophy. When a chest infection sends her to the ICU, the hospital suggests withdrawing care, and the once tight-knit family begins to splinter. This is the stuff of nightmares, but the acting is superb, and the writing manages to remain “witty and lively” even as the gut-wrenching power of the story encroaches.
“Best Interests” is a bit overlong, said Barbara Ellen in The Observer; given the amount of repetition, “at least one episode could have been chopped”. Still, “Thorne gets his essential messaging through (disabled lives have worth; disabled people are people), and, by God, he knows how to make the breaking human heart speak”.
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
There are clichés here and there, said Carol Midgley in The Times: within the first ten minutes, for instance, Andrew and Nicci have sex on a cluttered kitchen worktop, despite there being “non-crumby surfaces nearby” (this, of course, “never happens”). But overall, this is a “wonderful, heart-shattering piece of work” that succeeds in making Marnie not a legal case, but a joyous, rounded person. “I defy anyone not to cry.”
Where to watch: BBC iPlayer
-
Quiz of The Week: 15 – 21 NovemberQuiz Have you been paying attention to The Week’s news?
-
Can the UK do more on climate change?Today's Big Question Labour has shown leadership in the face of fraying international consensus, but must show the public their green mission is ‘a net benefit, not a net cost’
-
The Week Unwrapped: Will US Catholics rebel against the Pope?Podcast Plus what are the ethics of freezing your late partner?
-
Nick Clegg picks his favourite booksThe Week Recommends The former deputy prime minister shares works by J.M. Coetzee, Marcel Theroux and Conrad Russell
-
Park Avenue: New York family drama with a ‘staggeringly good’ castThe Week Recommends Fiona Shaw and Katherine Waterston have a ‘combative chemistry’ as a mother and daughter at a crossroads
-
Jay Kelly: ‘deeply mischievous’ Hollywood satire starring George ClooneyThe Week Recommends Noah Baumbach’s smartly scripted Hollywood satire is packed with industry in-jokes
-
Motherland: a ‘brilliantly executed’ feminist history of modern RussiaThe Week Recommends Moscow-born journalist Julia Ioffe examines the women of her country over the past century
-
Music reviews: Rosalía and Mavis Staplesfeature “Lux” and “Sad and Beautiful World”
-
Dianarama examines the ‘extraordinary scale’ of Martin Bashir’s liesThe Week Recommends Andy Webb’s book is packed with ‘astonishing’ allegations surrounding Princess Diana’s 1995 Panorama interview
-
6 homes for entertainingFeature Featuring a heated greenhouse in Pennsylvania and a glamorous oasis in California
-
Film reviews: ‘Jay Kelly’ and ‘Sentimental Value’Feature A movie star looks back on his flawed life and another difficult dad seeks to make amends
