Edinburgh reforms: is risk-taking in the City back?
Jeremy Hunt has announced new measures to ‘awaken the Square Mile’

Just months before “Brexit ejected him from the Treasury”, George Osborne “gave City bankers one final bashing for their sins”, said Simon Foy in The Daily Telegraph.
In March 2016, the then-chancellor introduced a new law allowing senior bankers to be jailed for up to seven years “if their risk-taking was deemed to be egregious enough”. The move terrified City executives; but now, after years of stagnation, priorities have changed.
Last week, Chancellor Jeremy Hunt watered down the “senior managers’ regime” – in one of “30 regulatory reforms” designed “to awaken the Square Mile” and bolster its position as an international financial centre. Dubbed the “Edinburgh Reforms” (because they were announced there), or Big Bang 2.0, the measures will also loosen the capital “ringfencing” rules for retail banks; mandate financial regulators to focus on economic growth and competitiveness; and allow pension funds to invest in a wider range of assets. “Risk-taking in the City is back with a bang.”
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
Mixed reactions
The plan was applauded in the City. But elsewhere, the reaction was one of horror, said Kalyeena Makortoff in The Guardian. Sir John Vickers, the economist who led the inquiry into the UK banking industry after the 2007-08 crisis, said the Chancellor may be taking Britain down an “extremely dangerous path”.
Vickers is “particularly concerned” about plans to roll back ringfencing rules that protect savers by separating their deposits from riskier investment banking operations. Although targeted at smaller banks, they could also result in larger operators, such as NatWest and Lloyds, “facing fewer restrictions on how they fund their operations”, while enabling them “to sell more complex products to customers”.
‘Debatable’ proposals
Hunt is right, said Lex in the FT: “over-stringent banking regulation fosters the stability of a graveyard”. But while some proposals, such as loosening the EU-imposed Mifid II regulatory regime, are “undeniably welcome”, others are “debatable”.
Rather than abandoning “the principle of accountability” for senior managers, it would be better to enforce it narrowly but strictly. And anything other than “minor tweaks” to ringfencing would be a mistake – it might boost competition, but at the cost of requiring “future bailouts”.
The regulatory cycle follows “a well-worn pattern”, said Patrick Hosking in The Times. “A market crash, or consumer scandal leads to howls for something to be done and an abrupt tightening of the rules.” Then these safeguards get slowly chipped away – until the next crash. “Too much City ‘growth’ and innovation… is built on nothing more than complexity and leverage.” They’ve tried “unleashing the City’s potential before”. It didn’t end well.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
-
The week's best photos
In Pictures A tomato fight, painting behind bars, and more
-
Mountainhead: Jesse Armstrong's tech bro satire sparkles with 'weapons-grade zingers'
The Week Recommends The Succession creator's first feature film lacks the hit TV show's 'dramatic richness' – but makes for a horribly gripping watch
-
Seeing Each Other: Portraits of Artists – a 'riveting' exhibition
The Week Recommends Pallant House exhibition offers fascinating instances of painterly reciprocity
-
Mortgages: The future of Fannie and Freddie
Feature Donald Trump wants to privatize two major mortgage companies, which could make mortgages more expensive
-
Pocket change: The demise of the penny
Feature The penny is being phased out as the Treasury plans to halt production by 2026
-
The UK-US trade deal: what was agreed?
In Depth Keir Starmer's calm handling of Donald Trump paid off, but deal remains more of a 'damage limitation exercise' than 'an unbridled triumph'
-
Shaky starts: A jobs drought for new grads
Feature The job market is growing, but Gen Z grads are struggling to find work
-
Work life: Caution settles on the job market
Feature The era of job-hopping for bigger raises is coming to an end as workers face shrinking salaries and fewer opportunities to move up
-
What is the job market's future after Trump's tariffs?
Talking Points Economic analysts are split on what the tariffs could mean for employees
-
Saving the post office
Feature The U.S. Postal Service is facing mounting losses and growing calls for privatization. Can it survive?
-
Safe harbor: Gold rises as stocks sink
feature It's a golden age for goldbugs