The BBC has apologised for not challenging Lord Lawson after he claimed official figures show average world temperatures have “slightly declined” over the last decade.
Lawson, an avid climate-change denier, told BBC Radio 4’s Today in August that world temperatures had not risen in the past ten years, even though the scientific community says the world has seen record-breaking temperatures for the last three years, the The Guardian reports.
Listeners complained after interviewer Justin Webb failed to challenge the claim, which was also contradicted by the Met Office.
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
Today disregarded the initial complaints by saying the Tory peer's views were similar to those of the current US administration and it was important to offer space to “dissenting voices”.
However, the complaints unit ultimately ruled the show had breached “its guidelines on accuracy and impartiality”, the BBC says, and that while the corporation offers time for dissenting views, Lawson’s claims were contestable and should have been challenged.
“Even a sixth-former would be able to tell you that wasn't so,” said one of the original complaints, retired GP Tim Thornton.
“So the BBC interviewer, if they are talking about climate change, should have done a little bit of homework.”
Twitter users applauded the BBC for apologising, but urged it not to make the same mistakes again:
However, others were not satisfied:
The Global Warming Policy Forum, of which Lawson is a chair, acknowledged that the temperature data he referred to was “erroneous”.
This is not the first time an interview with Lawson has received complaints. In 2014, Today was judged to have “given undue weight to Lord Lawson’s views” on one episode and had “conveyed a misleading impression of the scientific evidence on the matter”.
-
Homes with great fireplacesFeature Featuring a suspended fireplace in Washington and two-sided Parisian fireplace in Florida
-
Is $140,000 the real poverty line?Feature Financial hardship is wearing Americans down, and the break-even point for many families keeps rising
-
Film reviews: ‘The Secret Agent’ and ‘Zootopia 2’Feature A Brazilian man living in a brutal era seeks answers and survival and Judy and Nick fight again for animal justice
-
Death toll from Southeast Asia storms tops 1,000speed read Catastrophic floods and landslides have struck Sri Lanka, Indonesia, Thailand and Malaysia
-
Can for-profit geoengineering put a pause on climate change?In the Spotlight Stardust Solutions wants to dim the sun. Scientists are worried.
-
How will climate change affect the UK?The Explainer Met Office projections show the UK getting substantially warmer and wetter – with more extreme weather events
-
Can the UK do more on climate change?Today's Big Question Labour has shown leadership in the face of fraying international consensus, but must show the public their green mission is ‘a net benefit, not a net cost’
-
Did Cop30 fulfil its promise to Indigenous Brazilians?Today’s Big Question Brazilian president approves 10 new protected territories, following ‘unprecedented’ Indigenous presence at conference, both as delegates and protesters
-
Can the world adapt to climate change?Today's Big Question As the world gets hotter, COP30 leaders consider resilience efforts
-
Taps could run dry in drought-stricken TehranUnder the Radar President warns that unless rationing eases water crisis, citizens may have to evacuate the capital
-
The future of the Paris AgreementThe Explainer UN secretary general warns it is ‘inevitable’ the world will overshoot 1.5C target, but there is still time to change course
