The popularity of crime stories shows no sign of diminishing.
"Bookshop shelves and TV schedules are heaving with murder mysteries and whodunnits," said Holly Spanner at BBC Science Focus.
There are plenty of new fictional crime thrillers and crime dramas around in 2024, but the true crime genre has also "been given a new lease of life in recent years", with several "smash-hit documentaries".
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Here are some recent ones that have shed light on some tragic real-life stories.
They Called Him Mostly Harmless
The "best and worst of the internet are on full display", said The Daily Beast of this 2024 documentary. When a male body was found in a tent in Florida's Big Cypress National Preserve in 2018, with no ID, it took two years to identify him as the Appalachian Trail hiker Vance Rodriguez. He had been known by some as "Mostly Harmless" as that was how he would introduce himself to fellow walkers. The documentary shows how online detectives discovered his real name and how revealing his identity "came with bombshells about the man so many had turned into a romantic victim of mysterious circumstances".
From the creators of "The Tinder Swindler", this three-part 2024 docuseries follows the bizarre story of what the media dubbed a "real-life Gone Girl ruse", said James Mercadante in Entertainment Weekly. On March 23 2015, Aaron Quinn called 911 to report that he and his girlfriend, Denise Huskins, had been attacked in their home by an intruder who blindfolded and drugged them, then abducted Denise in the boot of his white Mustang car. It wasn't long before fingers were pointing at Quinn as the prime suspect. That was until Denise suddenly reappeared. This is more than just the retelling of an unbelievable crime. It also dissects "matters such as the stigmatization of rape survivors" and the influence of "pop culture on our collective consciousness".
When a decaying corpse wrapped in 41 layers of plastic turns up in the "sleepy" village of Beddau in south Wales, the community is "shaken", said Emily Watkins on the i news site. As we start to hear from locals, an elderly woman soon emerges as the prime suspect: Leigh Sabine. Expertly mixing the "claustrophobia" of a small town with a "family mystery spanning generations", the first episode of the three-part series sets a compelling scene. "It's been a long time since a film gripped me quite like Sky's stylish and surprising 'The Body Next Door'".
More a "how-could-she-do-it?" than a whodunnit, the "breathlessly twisty investigation" makes us face up to a person whose actions range from "heartless to inexplicably vile", said Rachel Aroesti in The Guardian. The "addictively watchable" show flits between 1970s New Zealand, 1980s Reading and 2010s Beddau, covering many "fascinating themes" including generational trauma, maternal neglect and coercive control. There's no need for any "glacial recapping" or fillers: threaded through the police investigation to identify the body is another "jaw-dropping" transgression.
This three-part German-language docuseries details "the hunt for the man dubbed the Darkroom Killer by the press" after several young men were murdered in Berlin in 2012, with one body found in one of the "dimly lit anonymous sex spaces that are a feature of gay clubs around the world", said The Guardian. The police "talk us through what seems like the very model of a well-run police operation", after their "decisive initial determination that a crime has taken place". Because with "no witnesses, no visible marks on the body and no sign of a struggle, it would have been possible to assume a self-administered drug overdose, mark it up as an accidental death and move on", as has happened elsewhere. The killer remained at large until "one of his victims survived", said GQ magazine. Produced by the "team behind other Netflix docs like 'Jeffrey Epstein: Filthy Rich' and 'The Vanishing at the Cecil Hotel', 'Nightlife Killer' will be one to earmark".
In November 2010, Jennifer Pan phoned 911 in Toronto, "stating that men had broken into their home, shot both her parents and fled", said the Daily Express. The 24-year-old's Vietnamese-born parents had been tied up and taken to the basement. Her mother had died, but her father was still alive. However, "the case had a few unusual details that raised questions with investigators", said the London Evening Standard. The front door had been unlocked, and Pan hadn't been taken to the basement by the men.
Pan's parents had always "put a huge emphasis on academic achievement", and she and her brother "had restricted social lives". After her "grades started slipping" at the age of 14, she began faking results and reports, even pretending to go to university. "The charade continued for years" until Pan's lies were exposed, when the "murderous plotting seems to have begun". A boyfriend put Pan in contact with a "well-connected criminal", and "they agreed on a $10,000 fee for the hitman job". In December 2014, Pan was convicted of first-degree murder and attempted murder, and along with the assailants, was given a life sentence. In May 2023, the four were granted a new trial due to procedural error, with the date yet to be set. Pan still maintains her innocence.
In 2021, the body of five-year-old Logan Mwangi was found in a river near his home in Bridgend, South Wales. This harrowing documentary "follows the investigation from the moment Logan was reported missing", said Stuff, to the arrest and conviction for murder of Logan's mother, Angharad Williamson, her partner John Cole and his son Craig Mulligan, who were jailed in 2022.
"There's a tricky balance in true crime storytelling," said the website, "between information, entertainment and exploitation – that is missed all too often." The sad story is "told with actual footage rather than dramatisation or excessive interviews" and provides an "important watch, without any ruse of entertainment".
In the hour-long programme, Logan's biological father, Ben, said: "One of the biggest questions in my whole entire life that I will always be asking myself is why? Why did this happen? Why did Logan have to die?" said The Sun.
"The odd thing about the characters" in this saga is "how familiar they are from fiction", said The Telegraph: "a powerful family ruling over a small town. An indulged and entitled son who thinks he's above the law. Corruption and murder in a Deep South setting."
This is the second season. The first featured a fatal boating accident: the wife and younger son of disgraced lawyer Alex Murdaugh were found dead. In March last year Murdaugh was found guilty of the murders a week after Season 1 of the docuseries dropped, and was given two consecutive life sentences. So season two's timing "is either incredibly timely or brazenly opportunistic – or, most likely, both", said Rolling Stone. And the filmmakers "do a fine job spinning the yarn, pulling the viewer this way and that, and letting the 'Can you top this?' details slowly pile up."
The shooting of John Lennon outside his New York home in December 1980 by Mark Chapman is "so well known that it's extraordinary to realise how much has never been revealed till now", said the Daily Mail, "and how many people have not been asked for their testimony". And the reason could be that "Chapman pleaded guilty to murder, surprising his own defence team, who expected him to claim he was 'not guilty by reason of insanity'" so "he never stood trial".
This "tense and economical documentary" has an "emotional punch", said the i news site, which "comes from the unflinching fashion" in which many of the eyewitnesses speak for the first time and "share their recollections, along with flinty narration by Kiefer Sutherland".
"Ever since I was a kid, I always wanted to be a criminal," says Ray Trapani in this "mesmerising documentary" featuring interviews with friends, family and "the journalist who exposed Centra Tech as the first high-profile fraud case of the crypto era". It charts the "founding, rise and crash of Centra Tech, the fraudulent firm of which he was CEO", said Mail Plus.
The "alluring pitch" of the company was the creation of a "debit card that allowed you to spend all your cryptocurrency in one place". After learning the "true story of the sheer illegality" that Trapani and his associates indulged in, "convincing investors to part with money under the guise of bitcoin smoke and mirrors", said Digital Spy, "it's hard to believe they got away with their Centra Tech scheme for as long as they did".
Almost 45 years after the crime, retired research scientist Christopher Harrisson was found guilty of the murder of his ex-wife, genetics expert Brenda Page, in Aberdeen. In 1978 there wasn't enough evidence for him to be brought to trial, but advances in forensics made it possible in February 2023.
Avoiding sensationalism, "it takes time for a show as demurely presented as 'Murder Trial' to reveal its worth", said The Guardian. The case is based on circumstantial evidence, with plenty of "back and forth between prosecution and defence as the crown presents its case" and then "we can enjoy one of the staples of a good true-crime documentary: a fascinatingly eccentric chief suspect".
When "the cravatted, octogenarian academic Harrisson" takes the stand, he is "introduced by the prosecution with footage of a bizarre police interview in which, when asked to describe his temper, he replies: 'Even. Like the snow in Good King Wenceslas.'"
"What appears at the beginning to be an open-and-shut case turns out to be anything but," said The Telegraph. When 13-year-old Tair Rada was found dead inside a locked toilet cubicle at her school in northern Israel, a contractor working there was arrested. But then we see the "oppressive methods by which the Israeli police gained that confession", and "every piece of evidence you saw in episode one is reappraised".
"Shadow of Truth" originally aired on a small cable channel. But it "immediately became a smash hit, one of the most watched Israeli programmes", said The Times. It "seemingly proved the power of true crime documentaries to make the justice system accountable". However, "in fanning murder fandom, it also brought out the worst of armchair detectives" in the quest to find the real killer.
Warren Jeffs led the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints (FLDS), an extreme sect of the Mormon faith, in Utah, having succeeded his father in the role in 2002. Jeffs began to impose new rules on followers, gradually turning the FLDS "from a fundamentalist Mormon sect to what the average person would recognise as a cult", said the i news site.
These new rules, covering underwear, hairstyles and wearing red, "bore most heavily down on the women". And "as the restrictions became harsher, Warren's wives (he has at least 69) got younger and younger. Women started to become currency."
This documentary is "compelling" because of its interviews with these women, "victims of circumstance forced into marrying older men under the guise of religion". Some were extremely young: one "was married off to a man at just 14" and Jeffs himself married a 12-year-old.
After the authorities heard about the events, Jeffs went on the run, but was caught and is now "serving life, plus 20 years". It's an "astounding" account so it's hardly surprising that "we're so enraptured" by this story of the church and its criminal leader.
Adrienne Wyper has been a freelance sub-editor and writer for The Week's website and magazine since 2015. As a travel and lifestyle journalist, she has also written and edited for other titles including BBC Countryfile, British Travel Journal, Coast, Country Living, Country Walking, Good Housekeeping, The Independent, The Lady and Woman’s Own.
Today's political cartoons - November 19, 2024
Band Aid 40: time to change the tune?
Starmer vs the farmers: who will win?
Magnificent Tudor castles and stately homes to visit this year
Vegetable cocktails are having a moment
Renegade comedian Youngmi Mayer's frank new memoir is a blitzkrieg to the genre
Drawing the Italian Renaissance: a 'relentlessly impressive' exhibition
Niall Williams shares his favourite books
Patriot: Alexei Navalny's memoir is as 'compelling as it is painful'
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button: a 'magical' show with 'an electrifying emotional charge'
Bird: Andrea Arnold's 'strange, beguiling and quietly moving' drama
