10 best true crime podcasts for 2025

From a "completely bananas" kidnapping to cold cases and "eye-popping" tales of fraud, here are some of the best true crime podcasts you can tune into now.

The Pitcairn Trials

It's harder than ever to root out true-crime gems, such is the volume of the genre's output, said James Marriott in The Times. Without question, though, Luke Jones's engrossing and "quietly horrifying" new series, "The Pitcairn Trials", is one; in fact, it is the "best true-crime series I've heard in a long time". The subject is the child sexual abuse scandal that erupted in the 1990s on Pitcairn Island, the tiny British territory in the South Pacific, inhabited by just a few dozen people, most of whom are descendants of the Bounty mutineers.

A Kent police detective, Peter George, was sent to investigate a rape allegedly committed by Shawn Christian, a direct descendant of Fletcher Christian, the leader of the 1789 mutiny. But what emerged was not mere "isolated incidents of criminality", but "an ingrained and possibly quite ancient culture of routine sexual abuse" of young girls. All this is handled by Jones with "admirable sensitivity"; and by "weaving in the strange history of Pitcairn", he creates a portrait "of one of the most unusual communities in the world", and not just "a lurid opportunity to gawk at human misery".

Subscribe to The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

Operation Seal Bay

Another standout new true-crime podcast is "Operation Seal Bay", from BBC Radio Wales, said Fiona Sturges in the FT. The bay in question lies near Newport, Pembrokeshire, where, in 1983, locals spotted groups of men hanging around the remote beach – only accessible from the sea – who did not look as though they'd come to admire the scenery. Fearing that they were poachers, out to empty lobster pots, local fishermen landed a boat on the beach.

"There, underneath a pile of rocks, they found a hatch, beneath which was a ladder leading to a large underground chamber." What unfolds from there is an "enjoyable crime caper", with sophisticated international criminals "ultimately undone by the intrinsic nosiness of rural populations".

Kill List

In my time as a podcast critic, "I have surfeited on horror", said James Marriott in The Times: I am now "blithely unsurprised by the depthless human capacity for evil". Yet "even I, a jaded, broken connoisseur of human turpitude", had my interest piqued by the premise of "Kill List", a podcast about a site on the dark web where members of the public arrange the contract killings of their enemies.

"Seeking house to be burned down with occupants inside. No survivors," runs a typical order, quoting a few thousand dollars. "Kill him and make it look like a car accident on the road," demands another. The twist, as journalist Carl Miller relates, is that the website is a scam, conning the homicidal. Miller "doesn't have any assassins on his hands. What he does have is a list of people whom he knows someone wants dead" – and decides to phone them to let them know. "This goes badly." It's a "fascinating story, well told and with less grisly leering over tragedy than is usual in the true-crime genre".

Dangerous Memories

The six-part Tortoise podcast Dangerous Memories is about a "small set of very posh young women" who all fell under the spell of the same self-styled "healer", said Miranda Sawyer in The Observer. Anne Craig presented herself as a lifestyle guru, and came warmly recommended to her clients as "that amazing healer lady". But she ended up dominating their lives, planting false memories of past abuse and cutting them off from their families and friends – in some cases for years.

These are devastating stories, told by three of the "brainwashed" young women, whose "well-educated accents and polite cadences sound utterly at odds with the awful situations they find themselves in". Hosted by Grace Hughes-Hallett, the series is a "sensitive telling of a really difficult story". I was "fascinated and horrified throughout".

The Trial of Lord Lucan

The Daily Mail's "The Trial" podcasts have taken listeners behind the scenes of a handful of high-profile criminal cases, including the prosecutions of Lucy Letby, Constance Marten and the teenage killers of Brianna Ghey. "The Trial of Lord Lucan" has a twist: the case never made it to court. John Bingham, the seventh Earl of Lucan, was accused of murdering his children's nanny, Sandra Rivett, and attempting to kill his wife, Veronica, on 7 November 1974, but disappeared the same night and was never seen again.

After getting their hands on a previously unearthed document written by the investigating officer at the time, hosts Caroline Cheetham and Stephen Wright draft in two real-life barristers to take on the roles of prosecution and defence. "As always, it is nostalgia that fires up interest," said William Sitwell at The Telegraph. The story includes "exquisite nuggets", from the "rarity of an aristo accused of murder" to the "bedraggled sight of Lady Lucan fleeing to the Plumbers Arms screaming 'Murder, murder!'", as well as "the Cluedo-like instruments of murder: lead piping and a US mail bag".

The Price of Paradise

"The Price of Paradise" is a cold case podcast but "blimey, it's a hot one", said Miranda Sawyer in The Guardian. The madcap happenings kick off when mum-of-three Jayne Gaskin decides to sell the family home, buy a tiny island off the coast of Nicaragua and "drag" her partner and children to live there. She calls it Janique ("a combination of Jayne, Mustique and unique"). Other than the family's "one-room shack and some mangrove trees", there's nothing there, except, of course, a TV crew, which is filming them for a Channel 4 show, "No Going Back".

Presenter Alice Levine, whose "humorous delivery and script tweaks are a highlight", describes the subsequent events, including the whole family being kidnapped by gangsters (they escape). And if it couldn't get any madder – some locals angrily explain that Janique belongs to them, and the family discover that the shack is a stop-off point for cocaine smugglers. The story is "completely bananas" and "a binge-er".

White Devil

When veteran police superintendent Henry Jemmott was shot dead in Belize three years ago, Jasmine Hartin, the 32-year-old partner of Lord Ashcroft's son, was found covered in blood, not far from his floating body. Hartin told police the shooting had been an accident and she was charged with manslaughter by negligence. "Everyone assumed," said Deadline, "given her father-in-law's influence in Belize, that she would simply pay a fine and walk free back into her privileged life." Instead, she was "locked away in the country's most notorious prison, iced out by her adopted family, cut off from its fortune".

Presenter Josh Dean spent 18 months investigating for the "White Devil" podcast for Campside Media, "talking often to Hartin and the ever-shrinking circle of confidantes around her", as well as Belizean locals, journalists and expats. "The story is a trojan horse into a sprawling yarn about power, corruption, and the dying embers of colonialism," said Dean.

The Coldest Case in Laramie

Serial Productions' "The Coldest Case in Laramie" follows host and New York Times journalist Kim Barker as she looks into the death of a college student, Shelli Wiley, who died in the Wyoming city in 1985. Barker is granted a "stunning amount of access" to material surrounding the cold case, including the original case files and recorded police interviews, said Slate's Laura Miller.

But if you're a true crime fan who needs "a definitive resolution pinning down who did it and why", then this "is not for you". This isn't a "clear-cut story of police incompetence", Miller noted. It's more of an "unsettling call and response between then and now", as sources remember – and appear to misremember – what happened on the fateful night of Shelli's death.

The Retrievals

"The Retrievals" investigates the agonising journey female patients went through at Yale Fertility Center. Women on IVF attended the fertility clinic for the "surgical procedure" of egg retrieval, but were given saline instead of fentanyl, resulting in "excruciating" pain, said The New York Times.

This five-part series is reported by Susan Burton, a staffer at "This American Life", who explores how we "tolerate, interpret and account for" women's pain, and what happens when it is "minimised or dismissed".

Filthy Ritual

True crime podcast writers have "already mined a rich seam of stories about fraudsters", said The Times, but "Filthy Ritual" is "a doozy". From the late 1990s to the early 2000s, Juliette D'Souza "conned £1 million out of credulous clients".

Her "new age racket", run from Hampstead in north London, saw people part with envelopes of cash as "a 'sacrifice' to be hung on a money tree in the Amazonian rainforest", among other activities. "Kudos" to this podcast's creators for "reshaking this money tree to bring listeners an eye-popping tale".

Have you missed the biggest news of the week? Or the stories that will shape our lives in years to come, when the passing hype of the day's headlines have faded from memory. That's what we explore on The Week's own award-winning podcast, "The Week Unwrapped", which seeks out under-reported stories with unexpected consequences. Listen on: Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts or wherever you find podcasts