Opinion

Making sense of April's job report

The sharpest opinions on the debate from around the web

The U.S. economy added 428,000 jobs in April, beating the Dow Jones estimate of 400,000 despite high inflation, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported Friday. Average hourly earnings also grew, a bit below estimates (but behind inflation). That said, the news isn't without downsides: The labor force participation rate dropped to a disappointing 62.2 percent, its lowest in three months, and stock futures fell in the report's wake. Here's what the experts are saying:

Expect the Fed to stay the course on rate hikes

On Wednesday, the Federal Reserve raised interest rates by 0.5 percent in an effort to combat record-high inflation plaguing the nation. But a decent jobs report is unlikely to convince the Fed to "abandon its hawkish plans," Paul Ashworth, chief U.S. economist at Capital Economics, told CNBC. Rather, the central bank's plan "is clearly working," observed journalist Matthew Yglesias. Bloomberg seemed to agree: "The strength of the gains gave a green light to the Federal Reserve to keep on its aggressive path of raising interest rates."

Wage growth and inflation

It seems that at least part of the reason the Fed has been so intent on raising interest rates is to prevent a so-called wage-price spiral, in which price increases beget wage increases that beget prices increases again. Per April's report, wages rose 5.5 percent annually, but average hourly earnings only increased 0.3 percent last month (that's compared with 0.5 percent in March). Though fast wage growth is better for workers (particularly when prices are so high), "it has also been threatening to keep inflation elevated, both as strong demand persists and as companies raise costs to cover climbing labor expenses," The New York Times writes. This month's slightly-moderated increase might therefore prove "welcome news" for the Fed "if it lasts."

Jason Furman, chair of the Council of Economic Advisers under former President Barack Obama, agreed: "Nothing in this will or should change what the Fed does in June, but is another sign that the underlying inflation trend may be lower than I thought and coming down."

Economist Mohamed A. El-Erian said the strength of April's report does not seem to be an immediate threat to the risk of a wage-price spiral. "No matter how you look at it," added Economic Policy Institute's Elise Gould, "nominal wage growth is moderating (and decidedly not accelerating)." "We can keep labor markets tight without feeding inflation," she continued.

Not yet 'mission accomplished,' but…

April's growth is positive — but it's "not yet mission accomplished," noted Economic Policy Institute President Heidi Shierholz. There's a "huge hole" in the labor market, but "that gap is closing rapidly," she said.

The economy is at a "pivot point," suggested Politico's Chief Economic Correspondent Ben White. That is, we're seeing "recovery with a lotta momentum," added University of Michigan economics professor and New York Times contributor Justin Wolfers. "It's hard to see where all that recession talk is coming from." If you're not pleased by April's jobs report, "you're a professional grump," he added.

And at least "for now," said New York Times economics reporter Ben Casselman, "I'm not reading too much into the one-month drop in the labor force." When taken alongside the last six months, "the labor force is growing, but not quite as quickly as we thought (or had hoped). Not great, but not enough to set off major alarm bells given other data."

More From...

Brigid Kennedy
Read All
Biden to sign police reform executive order
Joe Biden.
pens out

Biden to sign police reform executive order

Lachlan Murdoch on Fox News criticism: 'It is what it is'
Lachlan and Rupert Murdoch.
all part of the gig

Lachlan Murdoch on Fox News criticism: 'It is what it is'

A quick look at Tuesday's primaries
Brian Kemp.
off to the races

A quick look at Tuesday's primaries

Getting into law school shouldn't be easy
A trash can.
Opinion

Getting into law school shouldn't be easy

Recommended

Getting into law school shouldn't be easy
A trash can.
Brigid Kennedy

Getting into law school shouldn't be easy

Bill de Blasio's run for Congress, explained
Bill de Blasio.
Picture of Catherine GarciaCatherine Garcia

Bill de Blasio's run for Congress, explained

Does breastfeeding belong in the formula-shortage debate?
A baby bottle.
Picture of Harold MaassHarold Maass

Does breastfeeding belong in the formula-shortage debate?

Would cameras in the Supreme Court help build trust?
A videocamera.
Brigid Kennedy

Would cameras in the Supreme Court help build trust?

Most Popular

John Oliver has some complaints about Subway, the sandwich chain
John Oliver
Johnsplaining

John Oliver has some complaints about Subway, the sandwich chain

Why are airline ticket prices so high right now?
An airplane.
Briefing

Why are airline ticket prices so high right now?

Trump loses his grip on a Trumpified GOP
Donald Trump.
Opinion

Trump loses his grip on a Trumpified GOP