“Keir Starmer is no longer really in charge of this government,” said Michael Gove in The Spectator. Instead, the strings are increasingly being pulled by his energy secretary. Ed Miliband might have “messed it up” as Labour leader a decade ago, said Will Lloyd in The New Statesman, but he now has “real power and popularity” within the cabinet, the unions and the wider party membership.
‘Ventriloquist’s dummy’ Miliband’s “beliefs have deepened, not changed” over time, said Lloyd, and they have “influenced his colleagues, too, perhaps without them realising”. If Andy Burnham or Angela Rayner were to become Labour leader, they wouldn’t “deviate from the script Miliband has written”.
I have news for anyone who fears such a development, said Gove in The Spectator: this is already Miliband’s administration. Starmer’s foreign policy, economic policy, “political positioning” and “very quest for meaning” are “All. Ed. Miliband.” He has his hand up Starmer’s back “where a spine should be, controlling the ventriloquist’s dummy”.
Starmer “dare not even ask” Miliband about his role in “deciding whether to exploit new oil and gas fields in the North Sea”, said Tom Harris in The Telegraph. Doesn’t he know his job is to lead the government, not to wait for Miliband to tell him what to do?
‘Soft left’ Miliband’s tenure as Labour leader “entrenched” the party’s “worst habits of self-loathing and internal schism”, lost them a general election and “set the stage for even worse”, said Sarah Ditum in The i Paper. Yet in appointing him to the cabinet, Starmer has “treated Miliband as an elder statesman, rather than the clown prince of the soft left”. Handing the energy brief “to a man whose history as leader is a catalogue of incompetence” may well ensure a “catastrophic swing back to fossil fuels under a Reform government”.
The departures of New Labourites Peter Mandelson and Morgan McSweeney have put Miliband’s soft left on the ascendent, said Daniel Finkelstein in The Times. Starmer is “still quite likely to fall”, and any subsequent leadership battle “can only be held or won from the Ed Miliband position”. Miliband will be Labour’s “most important political force, whatever his formal job”.
|