Talking Points

Neither side of the gun debate will budge. Now what?

It is by now a maddeningly familiar cycle. First comes horror and disgust as schoolchildren are murdered. It's followed by political polemics and grandstanding. Then, finally, a sense of fatigue and futility

The unstoppable force of out-of-control violence bumps into the immovable object that is America's entrenched gun culture, Second Amendment rights, and widespread private firearms ownership. Wishing away even the last of these, as those emulating the gun laws of other countries often do, makes the urgent calls to action harder to discern from the "thoughts and prayers" sentiments gun controllers increasingly find so irrelevant

That doesn't make the calls to action any less understandable. A civilized society does not permit children to be gunned down in their classrooms. But neither do we want them to poison their bodies with drugs. That fact has not made the war on drugs any more successful.

The prevalence of guns and their political salience to overwhelmingly law-abiding gun owners explain the intractability of this issue more than a gun lobby that, at an institutional level, has never been weaker. There may be half-measures on guns that could help, as well as other policies aimed at problems ranging from school security to mental health help, if there is a serious desire for solutions rather than simply a dodge. A debate on revised age requirements and improving the background checks system seems inevitable.

But a general, and often exaggerated, sense that guns are too easy to obtain combined with a revulsion at their lethality is not enough. Though Second Amendment advocates have their work to do, too. The problem of violence, both chronically in places like Chicago and episodically in places like Uvalde, Texas, is real and hits home like few other things. However debatable the proposed solutions, it is a problem that there will be an attempt to solve on someone's terms at some point.

In the meantime, except things to get uglier before they get better.

Recommended

DeSantis' no good, very bad week
Ron DeSantis at a podium
Behind the scenes

DeSantis' no good, very bad week

Amid Trump probe, Manhattan DA's office says it won't be 'intimidated'
Alvin Bragg.
standing firm

Amid Trump probe, Manhattan DA's office says it won't be 'intimidated'

New York Knicks legendary captain Willis Reed dies at 80
Willis Reed.
Rest in Peace

New York Knicks legendary captain Willis Reed dies at 80

LA school district in turmoil after 30,000 employees go on strike
A crowd gathers to support a strike against the LAUSD.
Shutting Down The District

LA school district in turmoil after 30,000 employees go on strike

Most Popular

Russia's spring Ukraine offensive may be winding down amid heavy losses
Ukrainian tank fires near Bakhmut
Attrition

Russia's spring Ukraine offensive may be winding down amid heavy losses

Adam Gopnik recommends 6 classic books for literature fans
Adam Gopnik.
Feature

Adam Gopnik recommends 6 classic books for literature fans

Nearly 200 banks at risk of SVB-type collapse, study finds
Bank ATM.
not fun to hear

Nearly 200 banks at risk of SVB-type collapse, study finds