Why the New Mexico governor's gun ban backfired
Critics say the Constitution isn't the only reason to oppose a 30-day gun ban in the name of public health
A judge this week blocked New Mexico Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham's (D) emergency public health order suspending the right of citizens in the Albuquerque area from carrying guns on public property, openly or concealed. Lujan Grisham had just announced her 30-day gun ban on Friday, saying it would serve as a "cooling-off period" in which state leaders could discuss how to address New Mexico's high gun violence rates after several children died in recent shootings in Albuquerque and other parts of the state. Gun control campaigners had praised Lujan Grisham's "courage," Reuters reported.
The backlash was quick, as everyone — including Lujan Grisham — expected. Four gun rights groups immediately filed lawsuits challenging Lujan Grisham's "public health emergency" order, Reason noted. U.S. District Court Judge David Urias agreed, saying the policy violated a landmark 2022 Supreme Court ruling that gives Americans the right to carry guns for self defense under the Constitution's Second Amendment. And that's just one reason that liberals and conservatives alike objected to Lujan Grisham's drastic move. Here are some of the main gripes from both sides:
Nobody was willing to enforce a gun ban
The governor just made herself look "unserious" and "ineffectual," said The Wall Street Journal in an editorial. New Mexicans across the political spectrum rejected Lujan Grisham's gun ban "Diktat" instantly, "by acclamation," even before the judge made it official. More than 100 pistol-packing protesters marched through Albuquerque's Old Town on Sunday. State police declined to issue any citations, and Bernalillo County's Democratic sheriff, John Allen, said there was "no way we could enforce" such an obviously unconstitutional order. Lujan wanted to show she meant business, but she came off as "unserious." Let that be a lesson to any governor "tempted to violate the Constitution to make a political point."
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
This targeted the wrong people
Nobody's denying something must be done about gun violence, said the Albuquerque Journal in an editorial. There were "a record 120 homicides in Albuquerque last year, with 76 homicide victims this year as of Sept. 8." The threat of "random violent crime has gripped the city" since gunfire sprayed from a vehicle killed 11-year-old Froylan Villegas and critically injured his aunt as the family left an Albuquerque Isotopes minor league baseball game in a road-rage incident the day before Lujan Grisham issued her order. But the governor is going after the wrong people. Her "shocking and unprecedented fiat" would mostly affect "law-abiding citizens who have gone through the arduous process of obtaining a concealed carry permit."
Lujan Grisham is hurting her own cause
Gun violence is indeed a public health crisis, said Mark Joseph Stern in Slate. But the law Lujan Grisham was trying to use was "plainly aimed at infectious diseases," not anything deemed dangerous. Besides, there is "no evidence" that people who legally carry firearms publicly contribute "to the explosion in gun violence that moved Lujan Grisham to act." Still, these law-abiding citizens faced a $5,000 fine if they violated this ban. No wonder everyone from gun rights groups to the American Civil Liberties Union had problems with it. "The governor has leveraged an emergency health law to suspend a right protected by state statute, the state constitution, and Supreme Court precedent." That kind of overreach is a gift to Republicans who want to convince voters that Democrats want to take away your guns.
Ignoring Supreme Court rulings is a slippery slope
When politicians on either side of the political divide start suspending rights based on their values, "the slope is slippery and treacherous," said former prosecutor Dennis Aftergut at MSNBC. "Looking ahead, how much easier would it be for Trump — should he be re-elected in 2024 — to declare a future emergency to justify freezing freedom of the press or free speech rights if he can point to a Democratic governor's having set the precedent in 2023?" Lujan Grisham knew the legal challenges were coming but wanted, and got, a discussion about gun violence. But political leaders should leave the "civil disobedience" to private citizens who sometimes have to protest to be heard. Governors shouldn't ignore what the courts say. "That's how respect for the law gets diluted."
Create an account with the same email registered to your subscription to unlock access.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
Harold Maass is a contributing editor at The Week. He has been writing for The Week since the 2001 debut of the U.S. print edition and served as editor of TheWeek.com when it launched in 2008. Harold started his career as a newspaper reporter in South Florida and Haiti. He has previously worked for a variety of news outlets, including The Miami Herald, ABC News and Fox News, and for several years wrote a daily roundup of financial news for The Week and Yahoo Finance.
-
Today's political cartoons - October 3, 2024
Cartoons Thursday's cartoons - differences, similarities, and more
By The Week US Published
-
The Cabinet Minister: 'sparkling' comedy with a 'satirical sting'
The Week Recommends Nancy Carroll's revival of Arthur Wing Pinero's classic farce is a 'life-affirming triumph'
By Irenie Forshaw, The Week UK Published
-
Cosy stays around the world
The Blend About time life gave you a hug? Then check in here...
By Delilah Khomo Published
-
ATF finalizes rule to close 'gun show loophole'
Speed Read Biden moves to expand background checks for gun buyers
By Peter Weber, The Week US Published
-
Tennessee House GOP moves to expel 3 Democrats over 'disorderly' gun reform protest
Speed Read
By Peter Weber Published
-
Ron DeSantis signs bill to allow concealed guns without a permit
Speed Read
By Catherine Garcia Published
-
New Jersey man tried to board airplane with numerous firearms, DOJ says
Speed Read
By Justin Klawans Published
-
Alex Jones ordered to pay nearly half a billion in Sandy Hook damages
Speed Read
By Rafi Schwartz Published
-
Former Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe dies after being shot
Speed Read
By Peter Weber Published
-
Senate passes 1st major gun law in 25 years, sending it to the House for quick approval
Speed Read
By Peter Weber Published
-
Supreme Court rules NY concealed carry law violates 2nd Amendment
Speed Read
By Brigid Kennedy Published