Supreme Court split over challenge to Indian Child Welfare Act
The Supreme Court heard arguments Wednesday over the legality of the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA), a federal law that prevents Native children from being separated from their tribes.
The challenge to the statute comes from the state of Texas and a non-Native American adoptive family who argue the law violates the equal protection clause of the Constitution, The Wall Street Journal reports.
Challengers argue the ICWA "deprives children of an individualized assessment of their own best interests." Meanwhile, the defendants — the Biden administration and a number of Native tribes — argue the law allows for individual assessments but also considers the child's relationship with their tribe.
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
The court appeared to be split, with Justice Brett Kavanaugh remarking that Congress could not "say that white parents should get preference for white children in adoption, or that Latino parents should get preference for Latino children."
Other justices explained the classification was a political one and not a racial one, Reuters reports. "Congress is very clear ... that it thinks that this statute is critical to the continuing existence of the tribe as a political entity," Justice Elena Kagan said.
The 1978 statute was originally passed after Congress found that public and private adoption agencies had taken hundreds of Native American children, even forcibly, and placed them into homes and institutions with no connection to their tribes, explains NPR. "About a third of native children were adopted away," said Cherokee Nation chief Chuck Hoskin Jr., "[A]bout 85 percent were adopted outside of tribal families."
"Congress found that ICWA was in the best interest of the children," said defense lawyer Ian Gershengorn.
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
Devika Rao has worked as a staff writer at The Week since 2022, covering science, the environment, climate and business. She previously worked as a policy associate for a nonprofit organization advocating for environmental action from a business perspective.
-
The 5 best TV shows about the mobThe Week Recommends From the show that launched TV’s golden age to a Batman spin-off, viewers can’t get enough of these magnificent mobsters
-
Is the US in recession?Today's Big Question ‘Unofficial signals’ are flashing red
-
Dinosaurs were thriving before asteroid, study findsSpeed Read The dinosaurs would not have gone extinct if not for the asteroid
-
NY attorney general asks public for ICE raid footageSpeed Read Rep. Dan Goldman claims ICE wrongly detained four US citizens in the Canal Street raid and held them for a whole day without charges
-
Trump’s huge ballroom to replace razed East WingSpeed Read The White House’s east wing is being torn down amid ballroom construction
-
Trump expands boat strikes to Pacific, killing 5 moreSpeed Read The US military destroyed two more alleged drug smuggling boats in international waters
-
Trump demands millions from his administrationSpeed Read The president has requested $230 million in compensation from the Justice Department for previous federal investigations
-
Trump nominee in limbo after racist texts leakSpeed Read Paul Ingrassia lost Republican support following the exposure of past racist text messages
-
Trump begins East Wing demolition for ballroomspeed read The president’s new construction will cost $250 million
-
Appeals court clears Trump’s Portland troop deploymentSpeed Read A divided federal appeals court ruled that President Trump can send the National Guard to Portland
-
Millions turn out for anti-Trump ‘No Kings’ ralliesSpeed Read An estimated 7 million people participated, 2 million more than at the first ‘No Kings’ protest in June
