The race to replace Jens Stoltenberg as Nato chief

The tenure of Nato’s secretary general, Jens Stoltenberg, is set to end this September, and rumours of possible successors are swirling.

Stoltenberg, who served as prime minister of Norway from 2000 to 2001, and again from 2005 until 2013, has held the key post for almost nine years.

He was due to step down last autumn, but was kept on as leader for an extra year following the invasion of Ukraine.

Subscribe to The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

The post of secretary general must be selected unanimously by the 30 Nato members. However, the voices of the four most powerful economies – the US, Germany, France and the UK – “exercise inordinate influence, even if they don’t always claim the coveted position for themselves”, said Foreign Policy.

Whoever is chosen, they will be taking on the role at a crucial time. “The Russian war against Ukraine has given Nato a renewed sense of its vital role in the defence of Europe”, said The New York Times.

Who is up for the top job?

Few names have been officially thrown in the ring, but the list of rumoured contenders is long and varied.

It is custom that the US does not put its own candidate forward, because an American general traditionally takes the high-ranking role of Supreme Allied Commander Europe in the organisation.

However, the US does carry a lot of sway in the decision.

US officials familiar with the debate told The New York Times that Chrystia Freeland, the deputy prime minister and finance minister of Canada, is seen as a promising choice in Washington. Freeland is Canadian-Ukrainian, and has a strong stance on the conflict. She would also be the first woman to hold the job.

There is a concern, however, “that her Ukrainian grandfather, a grateful immigrant to Canada, was as a younger man involved with a Ukrainian nationalist movement that saw the Nazis as useful foils to counter the Soviets”. This could play into Russian hands.

The name of Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte has also been proffered as a promising option, said Politico. Asked about the speculation, however, Rutte said he wanted to “leave politics altogether and do something completely different”.

Estonia’s Prime Minister, Kaja Kallas, is “a worthy challenger” for the job, said Politico. Estonia, unlike Canada, spends at least 2% of its GDP on defence, which is a stated goal for member nations of Nato. However, Kallas “is seen as staunchly anti-Putin and has advocated against negotiating with him”, so her selection could be seen as an aggressive move.

A Baltic leader for Nato is in general viewed by some as a logical choice in the context of the Ukrainian conflict. Some Western capitals, however, would not support the move, said Politico, viewing it as “too hawkish when war is raging next door”.

Lithuanian Prime Minister Ingrida Šimonytė, Slovakia’s President Zuzana Čaputová and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen of Germany are other names that get thrown around, a European diplomat told Politico.

Could it be someone from the UK?

The UK’s defence secretary Ben Wallace has also been tipped repeatedly for the job.

Asked last year if he would be interested in succeeding Stoltenberg, Wallace “admitted it would be ‘a nice job’ but added that he ‘loved’ his role as defence secretary”, reports the Daily Mail.

Wallace is “popular” among Tory members and has not ruled out a bid for party leader in the future, though he twice declined to run last year.

Wallace or not, this is a job “London dearly wants as another symbol of its post-Brexit engagement in the world”, said The New York Times.

Boris Johnson, as well as his predecessors Theresa May and David Cameron, has also been touted for the Nato top job.

But given his past diplomatic gaffes, “it’s hard to imagine a role that Boris Johnson would be less well suited for than that of Nato secretary general,” said The New Statesman.

Will Stoltenberg definitely step down?

Many in the diplomatic community still feel another extension of Stoltenberg’s term is one of the most likely options, said VOA News.

This weekend, though, Nato spokesperson Oana Lungescu appeared to shut down rumours: “The mandate of Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg has been extended three times and he has served for a total of almost nine years. The secretary general’s term comes to an end in October of this year and he has no intention to seek another extension of his mandate.”

The “overall feeling”, one senior Nato diplomat told Politico, is that it is “time for fresh air”.

But the allies may end up “playing it safe after all, and sticking with Stoltenberg”, the magazine reports.