“We have to seize back the political megaphone, set the agenda more strongly and show that Labour is making a difference to people’s lives.” In her acceptance speech after winning Labour’s deputy leadership contest, Lucy Powell wasted no time in saying where she thinks her party has gone wrong.
Powell was recently sacked from her cabinet post as Leader of the House of Commons, and has suggested it might have been because she had given “feedback people didn’t want to hear”. Now, the Manchester Central MP has the power and profile to push Keir Starmer towards her vision of “bold policies, rooted in progressive Labour values”.
What did the commentators say?
Powell has “long been seen as more of a challenger to the current status quo” than her rival for the deputy leadership, Bridget Phillipson, said The Independent’s political correspondent Millie Cooke.
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
The contest was hardly a ringing endorsement of either candidate, with turnout at just over 16%. But Powell’s victory is being seen as “a call from the Labour membership for a new direction amid growing unhappiness” with Keir Starmer’s government.
“Openly critical” of the government’s “unforced errors” on welfare reform and the winter fuel payment, Powell has also called for an end to the two-child benefit cap and taken issue with the Equality and Human Rights Commission’s guidance on trans issues. These clear points of policy contention “mean she is likely, at least at first, to be a thorn in Sir Keir’s side.”
Her campaign was “shrewdly calibrated”, said The Observer’s associate editor Andrew Rawnsley. “Rather than throw bricks and bottles at everything the government has done”, she has made the case that Starmer “needs a ‘course correction’ and that too much ‘group-think’ at the top has led to electorally disastrous decisions”.
While the prime minister clearly favoured Phillipson for the role, he quickly claimed to be “delighted” to work with Powell. And there may be room to turn potential “peril” into “opportunity”. Powell could be deployed as a “punchy advocate of the party’s values and achievements and a facilitator of constructively critical conversation about where it is going wrong”. She has said she wants to “speak truth to power” but “her chances of being heard greatly depend on whether power is willing to listen”.
What next?
Powell is expected to remain on the backbenches, from where she will adopt a “submarine approach” to interventions around government policy, “rather than offering a running commentary”, said Sky News’ political editor Beth Rigby. Choosing her battles carefully will make her “harder to ignore”. But she could, in time, “become a lightning rod for discontent should the party’s fortunes remain as parlous as they are now”.
Next May’s elections for the Welsh Senedd are already being seen as a moment of maximum danger for Starmer, and the point when Powell’s influence could really matter.
If Labour loses its century-long dominance in Wales, then Starmer, “already a beleaguered figure, will undoubtedly face some calls to stand down”, said Morgan Jones in The Guardian. “It’s hard to picture Powell as the smiler with the knife – but equally difficult to imagine her being hugely energetic in any endeavours to keep Starmer in No. 10.”
-
A running list of everything Donald Trump’s administration, including the president, has said about his healthIn Depth Some in the White House have claimed Trump has near-superhuman abilities
-
NASA’s lunar rocket is surrounded by safety concernsThe Explainer NASA hopes to launch a new mission to the moon in the coming months
-
Why is Tulsi Gabbard trying to relitigate the 2020 election now?Today's Big Question Trump has never conceded his loss that year
-
How long can Keir Starmer last as Labour leader?Today's Big Question Pathway to a coup ‘still unclear’ even as potential challengers begin manoeuvring into position
-
What is at stake for Starmer in China?Today’s Big Question The British PM will have to ‘play it tough’ to achieve ‘substantive’ outcomes, while China looks to draw Britain away from US influence
-
Can Starmer continue to walk the Trump tightrope?Today's Big Question PM condemns US tariff threat but is less confrontational than some European allies
-
Alaa Abd el-Fattah: should Egyptian dissident be stripped of UK citizenship?Today's Big Question Resurfaced social media posts appear to show the democracy activist calling for the killing of Zionists and police
-
Is Keir Starmer being hoodwinked by China?Today's Big Question PM’s attempt to separate politics and security from trade and business is ‘naïve’
-
Nigel Farage’s £9mn windfall: will it smooth his path to power?In Depth The record donation has come amidst rumours of collaboration with the Conservatives and allegations of racism in Farage's school days
-
ECHR: is Europe about to break with convention?Today's Big Question European leaders to look at updating the 75-year-old treaty to help tackle the continent’s migrant wave
-
The launch of Your Party: how it could workThe Explainer Despite landmark decisions made over the party’s makeup at their first conference, core frustrations are ‘likely to only intensify in the near-future’
