The government has outlined its plans to compensate victims of the infected blood scandal, starting with interim payments of £210,000.
This will be a "down payment on a vast compensation package – payable to people 'infected and affected' by the scandal – which government officials say could cost more than £10bn", said the Financial Times.
But around 3,000 people have already died in what is widely regarded as the worst treatment disaster in NHS history, and campaigners are calling for repercussions beyond compensation.
What did the commentators say? The Infected Blood Inquiry, set up in 2018, published a 2,000-page report yesterday that said the British state "knowingly exposed" about 30,000 people to diseases including hepatitis and HIV via contaminated blood between 1970 and 1991. Inquiry chair Brian Langstaff said that the scale of the catalogue of failures was "horrifying" and that the truth had been hidden for decades.
Rishi Sunak said it was "a day of shame for the British state", and promised to pay "whatever it costs" in compensation. But while money remains "the only currency in which recognition of fault can be paid", said The Independent, it will be "far too little, far too late".
It is "no surprise" that victims are calling for former health secretary Ken Clarke, who was heavily criticised in the report, to be stripped of his peerage, said The Spectator's Steerpike. "Many heads should roll," said Sarah Boseley in The Guardian, "but many of the most culpable individuals are dead."
John Glen, the Cabinet Office minister dealing with the scandal, has refused to rule out criminal proceedings over the scandal. Former health secretary and now Greater Manchester mayor Andy Burnham wants wider change. He is calling for a "Hillsborough law" to impose a legal "duty of candour on public servants" to avoid future cover-ups.
What next? There will be "some satisfaction" for survivors that organisations and individuals were criticised, said Sky News. But they must "wait for another day" for prosecutions, because the Inquiries Act prohibits public inquiries from finding criminal or civil liability. If prosecutions are to come, it will be through the courts.
It should also be "a matter of grave concern that there is still no quick mechanism for addressing institutional failures of these kinds", said The Telegraph. This must be a "catalyst for reform". |