Emmanuel Macron has said France’s new voluntary national service programme, announced today, is not about “sending our youth to Ukraine”. The plan “stops short” of full conscription, said France 24, and will involve recruiting paid volunteers to sign up for 10 months of military service.
The growing realisation that Russian aggression could “easily spill into Europe” has put “intense pressure” on countries across the continent to “quickly expand the ranks of full-time soldiers and reservists that shrank during the post-Cold War peace”, said The New York Times.
What did the commentators say? The countries “closest to Russian borders”, such as Estonia, Finland, Latvia and Lithuania, already practise forms of conscription, said Katie Gatens in The Times. But the war in Ukraine, and recent Russian drone incursions into Nato airspace, “have reignited the debate across the continent”.
In Poland, “plans are under way for every man to go through military training”, said Patricia Cohen in The New York Times. Denmark recently expanded its military conscription lottery to include women, while Croatia has gone further, voting in October to reintroduce compulsory military service.
Germany this month opted for a “new military service” that does not reinstate conscription, which ended in 2011, but “does include the potential for that”, said Andreas Noll on DW. It marks the “first unmistakable shift in German security policy for a generation”, said Henry Donovan in The Spectator. Britain should “pay close attention”: this is “the minimum a serious country does when confronted with the concrete possibility of war on its own continent”.
What next? Measures to boost voluntary enlistment cannot get around the central problem that fewer than a third of EU citizens say they would fight for their country in a war, according to a 2024 Gallup poll.
France’s armed forces chief, General Fabien Mandon, warned last week that, while France has the resources to defeat Moscow, it lacked the “spirit”. “If our country falters because it is not prepared to accept – let’s be honest – to lose its children, to suffer economically because defence production will take precedence, then we are at risk.”
|