The “distractions of Donald Trump and Davos” proved an “opportune” moment for France’s state-owned rail operator SNCF to “slip out some news”, said Gavin Mortimer in The Spectator. Bonjour to Optimum, “the new and exclusive area of the train where kids are not welcome”. And, to ensure that “little Gallic brats” don’t disrupt the quiet, “even briefly”, this carriage will be “located at the end of the train to prevent other passengers from walking through the Optimum-dedicated area”.
‘Shocking’ and ‘sick’ “In a rare moment of unity”, French MPs of all political stripes have expressed “outrage”, said Mortimer in The Spectator. “It’s shocking,” Sarah El Haïry, France’s high commissioner for children, said on BFM. “Travelling with children is not a problem to be fixed, but a reality to be supported.” Left-wing MP François Ruffin said the ban shows that French society is “sick”, while right-wing former interior minister Bruno Retailleau, said it was “everything France must not become”.
The arrival of the child-free train carriage only adds to France’s ongoing debate about adults-only spaces, said The Guardian. Last year, Laurence Rossignol, a socialist senator, called for a curb on the rising number of child-free holiday resorts. “We can’t organise society by separating children off from ourselves in the way some establishments don’t take dogs,” she said. “Children aren’t troublesome pets.”
‘Right to tantrum-free spaces’ I think the child-free carriage is a “magnificent idea”, said Fiona McIntosh in The Independent. Now my daughters have grown up, I have “earned the right to tantrum-free spaces”. And it’s actually quite a reasonable proposition: the Optimum carriage is only available Monday to Friday during “peak business travel” on just 8% of the SNCF’s express trains in and out of Paris. “Surely this segregation is a win-win for everyone?” .
Hostility towards children in public places “is growing”, said Rachel Connelly in The Guardian. But making them “absent of children” speaks to a “fantasy” world where our lives “are totally detached from the lives of the people around us” – when, of course, they aren’t. Just imagine “if this fantasy were reality: our lives would be very small and boring”.
|