The Bullpen

How Obama's scandals could swing the GOP primaries

And why this is terrible news for Marco Rubio — and good news for Chris Christie

In America, we don't just pick presidents for who they are. We sometimes elect them because they're the opposite of the last guy.

This might be a form of psychological therapy, whereby we attempt to "work out" our past problems, but it seems to fulfill some sort of atavistic desire to exorcise demons.

In the wake of presidents like Johnson and Nixon and events like Vietnam and Watergate, a peanut farmer named Jimmy Carter became the beneficiary of this urge. After enduring eight years of George W. Bush's Texas swagger and malapropisms, we turned to a law professor named Barack Obama.

Each time, it was as if America said, "Let's do something entirely different. Let's spin the wheel."

So now, as scandals swirl around the Obama administration (IRS, James Rosen, Benghazi, AP, NSA — will it ever end?), it seems likely that the race to nominate a Republican to (hopefully) succeed Obama will be significantly shaped by this president's increasingly controversial tenure.

Just days after President Obama's second inaugural, I wrote that Sen. Marco Rubio probably had the best shot of being our next president. Considering the brewing backlash to Obama's scandals, I may have been wrong.

The problem with Rubio is that he was never the anti-Obama, but rather, "Our Obama." If conservatives were in the mood to "fight fire with fire" — to put up our young, smart, articulate, cosmopolitan conservative who says reasonable things — to be inspirational and talk about a new kind of hope and change and tell a personal story about the American Dream (our American Dream, this time) — then Rubio was perfectly cast.

But that strategy worked only so long as Obama was considered worthy of copying. And should these scandals continue, the American appetite might be for something altogether different.

Just as Obama was both a substantive and stylistic rejection of George W. Bush, so might Republicans look for someone completely different from Obama next time around. This is not to say that Rubio and Obama are identical. They're not. But it is to say that if you're looking for the opposite of Obama, you'd probably look somewhere else.

There are other reasons the Obama scandals hurt Rubio. Like every Republican worth his salt, Rubio can talk about the evils of big government. But that's not really his wheelhouse. He is better equipped to tap into Reagan's inspirational rhetoric — and George W. Bush's compassionate conservatism.

It is the rare politician who can play angry and friendly, hot and cold, and Rubio is not good at being angry. This is fine, except when the public is in an angry mood.

Since Obama's election, the conservative movement had already been heading in a more libertarian direction. That was true before the scandals. But the scandals reinforce this trend. This is a problem for Rubio.

Economist Arnold Kling has a new e-book out called The Three Languages of Politics. It is his contention that people who have differing ideologies are essentially speaking a different language. Progressives talk about the world as if it were a struggle between the oppressed and the oppressors. Conservatives view the world as a struggle between civilization and barbarism. And the libertarian worldview suggests it's all about freedom versus authoritarianism.

Rubio is good at speaking the conservative language. In fact, he's great at it. But these scandals really favor someone who is fluent in the libertarian language.

You might assume that this is a prime opening for Sen. Rand Paul, a libertarian-leaning conservative. And while there is little doubt that he has a chance, the truth is that the scandals might hurt both Rubio and Paul, for the simple fact that they are both unlucky enough to be U.S. senators serving in Washington, D.C.

In the decades prior to Watergate, the U.S. Senate was perhaps the stepping-stone to the presidency. This is not to say that men were elected to the presidency directly from the upper chamber (though that did happen for Kennedy), but Truman, Kennedy, Johnson, and Nixon had all served in the Senate.

After Watergate, something interesting happened. The next president to have served in the U.S. Senate — and let's be honest, he was there for a cup of coffee — was Barack Obama.

One could assume that this was merely a coincidence, or one could assume that it spoke to something larger — that the public decided to cast its lot with men who were removed from the trappings of power in Washington, D.C.

Who knows if history will repeat itself, but it is an argument for why Scott Walker, Chris Christie, Bobby Jindal, and Mike Pence (among others) should be taken very seriously.

More From...

Picture of Matt K. LewisMatt K. Lewis
Read All
What being a father taught me about God
Just as God knows what's best for me, I know what's best for my sons.
Opinion

What being a father taught me about God

U.S. workers' epidemic of demoralization
Matt K. Lewis
The Bullpen

U.S. workers' epidemic of demoralization

The honesty and dignity of Lindsey Graham
The senator will be missed this 2016 race.
Opinion

The honesty and dignity of Lindsey Graham

The political charade of Obama's Keystone rejection
President Obama speaks at the southern site of the Keystone pipeline in 2012.
Opinion

The political charade of Obama's Keystone rejection

Recommended

Republicans oust Ilhan Omar from House committee
Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-Minn)
Punitive politics?

Republicans oust Ilhan Omar from House committee

FBI investigating George Santos' role in dog fundraising scheme
George Santos.
'the big guys finally picked it up'

FBI investigating George Santos' role in dog fundraising scheme

Thousands mourn as Tyre Nichols is laid to rest in Memphis
Rev. Al Sharpton and Vice President Kamala Harris
Rest in peace

Thousands mourn as Tyre Nichols is laid to rest in Memphis

College Board appeases conservatives over AP African American studies
AP African American Studies textbooks
Advanced appeasement?

College Board appeases conservatives over AP African American studies

Most Popular

The Hogwarts Legacy boycott controversy, explained
Hogwarts Legacy logo photo
Briefing

The Hogwarts Legacy boycott controversy, explained

U.S. firm offers Ukraine 2 Reaper drones for $1, plus $10 million in shipping
MQ-9 Reaper drone
Fine Print

U.S. firm offers Ukraine 2 Reaper drones for $1, plus $10 million in shipping

Did Dry January accomplish anything?
Drinking glasses.
Opinion

Did Dry January accomplish anything?