Editor's letter: A plea for candor

Can you handle the truth? Ethicist Bruce Weinstein would like to think so. In The New York Times this week, Weinstein assails Barack Obama and Mitt Romney for trying to win this election with “shameful” attack ads, distortions, and scare tactics, combined with proposals that deliberately omit any painful details and whose math does not compute. Is it really so “unrealistic and naïve,” Weinstein asks, to expect candidates to put aside their “unbridled ambition,” and speak honestly to American voters about what ails us, and what bitter medicine we need to swallow?

Alas, Weinstein’s worthy plea shall fall on deaf ears. By its nature, politics screens out or corrupts the truth-tellers; you rise in that game only by pleasing 51 percent of the voters. Presidential candidates are, by definition, people of colossal ego and ambition, and they and the professional manipulators who surround them know from long experience that the surest way to win elections is to inflame voters’ fears, stoke their resentments, and pander to their selfish, short-term interests. Honesty? It’s called “a gaffe,” and will launch $25 million in scornful attack ads. The two campaigns may offer very different general philosophies, but they share a fondness for half-truths. Obama/Biden’s: If we just raise taxes on the top 1 or 2 percent, we can put off dealing with exploding Social Security, Medicaid, and social service costs until…well, later. Romney/Ryan’s: We can wipe out a $1 trillion annual budget deficit without a penny in new taxes, by simply cutting everyone’s taxes even further, taking an axe to unspecified spending, and leaving society’s losers to their fate. Can you handle the truth? The candidates obviously don’t think so.

William Falk

Subscribe to The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

Note to readers

The Week will not publish an issue for one week. Your next issue will arrive in two weeks. Our next edition will be dated Sept. 7, and should begin arriving on Aug. 31. The Week currently publishes 48 issues a year. Subscribers, of course, are not charged for weeks in which there is no issue.

Corrections

In our Aug. 3 Briefing, “Intrigue at the Vatican,” we stated that Catholic priests take a vow of poverty. In fact, while members of most religious orders take that vow, diocesan priests do not. In the same issue, the caption of a photo of Monsignor William Lynn, who was sentenced for child endangerment in Philadelphia, referred to him as “Flynn.” We regret the errors.