Should Tim Tebow start for the Jets?

The Jets' No. 2 quarterback outperformed his team's starter Mark Sanchez in the preseason opener, making some wonder whether Tebow is better for the offense

New York Jets quarterback Tim Tebow warms up before a preseason NFL game against the Cincinnati Bengals Aug. 1.
(Image credit: Joe Robbins/Getty Images)

Quarterback Tim Tebow made his Jets debut against the Bengals in a preseason game over the weekend, completing four of six passes and throwing one pick. The former Bronco passed for a total of 27 yards and added 34 more rushing as the Jets unveiled a secret new "Wildcat"-style offense that gives them the option to play to Tebow's strengths as a runner. Yet the newcomer's contentious relationship with current Jets starter — and arguably perennial underachiever — Mark Sanchez remains one of the bigger story lines early on in this NFL season, as the two fight for the same job. While neither looked particularly dominant in the opener (Sanchez finished four of six passes for just 21 yards), the Jets are looking to rebound from a disappointing 2011-2012 season where they finished with eight wins and eight losses. Tebow, who captivated NFL fans last season with an unlikely string of victories, could potentially give the team the spark it desperately needs. Should coach Rex Ryan pull the trigger and supplant the incumbent Sanchez with his God-fearing rival?

It's worth considering: Making Tebow a starter is "not inconceivable," says Chris Trapasso at Bleacher Report, and could actually make the Jets better. Tebow is a powerful runner, and Coach Ryan has said repeatedly that he wants to return to a "ground-and-pound" offense that sidesteps the Jets' passing deficiencies. If Tebow has indeed improved as a thrower like he said he has, it would theoretically negate any advantage that starting Sanchez (an average passer in his own right) would provide while giving the team the added dimension of a running game. Naming Tebow the starter after limited preseason action "wouldn't be fair to Sanchez, but, sometimes, the NFL isn't fair."

"Can Tim Tebow take the starting job in New York before opening weekend?"

Subscribe to The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.


Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

No. Sanchez is still the man: "All the talk, hype, and attention devoted to Tim Tebow can take a big hit if Mark Sanchez does one thing," says Justin Terranova at the New York Post: "Play well." Tebow may grab all the headlines, but as the Jets' upper brass reiterated during the off-season, Sanchez is still the starter, even though he'll have to make due with a lack of worthy targets (save Santonio Holmes, with whom Sanchez reportedly has an icy relationship ). If Sanchez plays even halfway decent to start the season off, the question of whether a shaky but exciting Tebow should replace him will be a non-issue.

Jets' Sanchez will face 'brutal' situation if he struggles

Unfortunately, this question will just keep coming up: Anytime Tebow "does anything, good or bad, quarterback or otherwise," people are going to draw conclusions about what that means for Mark Sanchez, says Will Leitch at New York. The Jets brought this upon themselves. Saying that Sanchez was and still is their guy "is the reason the trade for Tebow was so odd in the first place." All New York managed to do was create another media circus. "People are going to speculate — not just media, but players and fans and anyone keeping so much as a cursory eye on the team." And when the Jets play their next exhibition on Saturday night against the crosstown rival Giants, we "get to go through all this all over again."

"The Tebow madness is upon us"

Continue reading for free

We hope you're enjoying The Week's refreshingly open-minded journalism.

Subscribed to The Week? Register your account with the same email as your subscription.