What happened
Iraqi leaders this week struggled to break an impasse over a new constitution, with Shiites and Sunnis deadlocked over the role of Islam in the new government and Kurds demanding the right to self-rule. Kurds were insisting that Iraq's first democratic constitution set up a federal system that preserves their autonomy in the north; Sunni representatives to the drafting committee objected, fearing that dividing the country into three, largely autonomous states would leave them as a powerless minority, with little claim to Iraq's oil wealth. Most of Iraq's oil fields are concentrated in the Kurdish north and the Shiite south. Under interim rules, a draft must be completed by Aug. 15. 'œWe are in a race against the clock,' said Mahmoud Othman, a member of the drafting committee.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
What the editorials said
So much for a democratic beacon in the Mideast, said Newsday. Leaked drafts of the constitution 'œfall far short' of U.S. ideals for Iraq. It appears to set up a largely Islamic state, with Islamic law trumping 'œbasic individual rights,' such as equal rights for women, freedom of religion, and the right to political dissent. If the Bush administration doesn't exert pressure on the drafting committee to change this backward document, Iraq will resemble Iran more than it does the U.S.
That's way too pessimistic, said the Chicago Tribune. This won't be the first time Iraq has 'œdefied the doubters.' In January, skeptics called for delaying the election of an interim government, saying terrorists would make it a bloodbath. Instead, election day was 'œan inspiring mass repudiation of the terrorists.' Even if the constitution doesn't 'œease all frictions between Shiites, Sunnis, and Kurds,' it will mark the 'œstarting point' for making Iraq a nation 'œgrounded in the rule of law.'
What the columnists said
However the constitution comes out, said Paul Findley, also in the Tribune, the U.S. must now announce a date for withdrawing its 140,000 troops'”say, six months from now. The neocons want us to stay until Iraq is at peace, but the U.S. has already paid too high a price, in casualties and in damage to our international reputation. With feuding factions now struggling for power, 'œcivil strife' is inevitable, and it will probably last for years. 'œUltimately, Iraqis will have to solve their own internal conflicts if their nation is to be truly independent.'
The desire to cut and run is 'œunderstandable,' said Frederick W. Kagan in the Los Angeles Times, but 'œwrongheaded.' Despite the insurgents' ability to inflict 'œa steady stream of casualties,' as a military force they are impotent. They can't go 'œtoe-to-toe' with American soldiers. And every day we are training more Iraqi troops to eventually take our place. Pulling out prematurely would only give the insurgency room 'œto grow, perhaps becoming what it now is not'”a real military threat to the government.'
Tell that to the Pentagon, said William Kristol in The Weekly Standard. In recent weeks, Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld has been trying to define victory down; no longer is he saying that it's necessary or even possible to defeat the insurgency. He's now adopted the view of liberal opponents of the war'”that we might as well withdraw and let Iraqis fight the insurgency themselves. Let's hope President Bush does not give in to this 'œdefeatism.' Iraq is, as Bush has said all along, 'œthe central front in the war on terror,' and true victory over the insurgents is our only option.
What next?
The Providence Journal
The Wall Street Journal
-
August 10 editorial cartoonsCartoons Sunday's political cartoons include a global plastics problem, GOP enthusiasm over tariffs, and more
-
5 thin-skinned cartoons about shooting the messengerCartoons Artists take on unfavorable weather, a look in the mirror, and more
-
Is Trump's new peacemaking model working in DR Congo?Talking Point Truce brokered by the US president in June is holding, but foundations of a long-term peace have let to be laid
-
Putin’s threat to fracture Ukrainefeature Fears that Russia was building a pretext for an invasion of eastern Ukraine grew, as pro-Kremlin protesters occupied government buildings in three cities.
-
Curbing NSA surveillance
feature The White House said it will propose a broad overhaul of the National Security Agency’s domestic surveillance program.
-
Downsizing the military
feature A new budget plan for the Pentagon would save hundreds of billions of dollars by taking the military off its post-9/11 war footing.
-
Putin ratchets up pressure on Ukraine
feature Russian President Vladimir Putin put 150,000 troops at the Ukraine border on high alert and cut off $15 billion in financial aid.
-
Ukraine on the brink of civil war
feature Ukraine’s capital was engulfed in flames and violence when hundreds of riot police launched an assault on an anti-government protest camp.
-
Ukraine at the breaking point
feature An alliance of opposition groups vowed protests would continue until President Viktor Yanukovych is removed from power.
-
Dim prospects for Syrian talks
feature A long-awaited Syrian peace conference in Montreux, Switzerland, quickly degenerated into a cross fire of bitter accusations.
-
The fight over jobless benefits
feature A bill to restore federal benefits for the long-term unemployed advanced when six Republican senators voted with Democrats.